Army Failed for a Decade To Prosecute ‘Serial Rapist’ — Then His Daughter Came Forward

April 12, 2021James R. Webb
Army serial rapist CID sentenced

US Army Staff Sgt. Randall Hughes, shown in an official Army photo, was sentenced to 13 years and a dishonorable discharge for multiple sexual crimes. US Army photo/released.

After slipping through the cracks for more than a decade, Army Staff Sgt. Randall Hughes has been prosecuted for a slate of sexual crimes including multiple counts of rape and sexual assault, including the 2020 rape of his own daughter. 

While Hughes will spend the next 13 years in prison and receive a dishonorable discharge, it wasn’t until Hughes’ own daughter reported him for drugging and raping her in a March 25, 2020, incident that the Army’s Criminal Investigative Division began to fully investigate the multiple instances logged in Hughes’ personnel record. 

The first allegations of rape against Hughes date back to 2006, although the incident was not reported at the time, and the plea deal resulted in that charge being dropped. According to Army investigators, Hughes, while stationed at Fort Carson, Colorado, raped his then-wife. 

In 2017, the incident that would eventually mar his record — though still not result in prosecution — took place following a Super Bowl party at a subordinate’s house near Fort Bliss, Texas.

harassment army rape
Soldiers assigned to 3rd Infantry Brigade Combat Team, 25th Infantry Division, participate in the “Teal Line Up” in support of Sexual Assault Awareness and Prevention Month at Schofield Barracks, Hawaii, on Thursday, April 8, 2021. This group of soldiers wore teal attire and held signs and banners while walking through unit areas during morning physical readiness training to bring awareness. US Army photo by Staff Sgt. Alan Brutus, courtesy of DVIDS.

According to reporting by Kyle Rempfer in the Army Times, Hughes raped Leah Ramirez, the wife of a soldier in Hughes’ charge, after deliberately getting her husband so drunk he passed out. After Ramirez put her husband to bed, and the party had ended, Ramirez found herself alone with Hughes, at which point he propositioned her for sex. After she declined his advances, Hughes grabbed her by the hair and raped her inside her own house.

“I waited until the morning and then I went to the hospital to get checked,” recalled Ramirez — who agreed to be named by the Army Times to encourage any other victims to come forward. “It took CID 48 hours to get into my house for evidence, so I lived in the crime scene for 48 hours.”

The Army’s Criminal Investigative Division launched an investigation into the incident. However, it took a year before CID deemed the allegations credible. But instead of being prosecuted, Hughes received a General Officer Memorandum of Reprimand, or GOMOR, in his personnel file. Meanwhile, Hughes’ actions remained unchecked while the allegations were not public.

serial rapist sentenced
A sign from Fort Bliss denotes the end of the military installation on the base’s far east side. Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

“I was told CID had enough evidence to believe it happened, and Fort Bliss still didn’t do anything,” Ramirez told the Army Times. “They just told me the command said this is what it was — this is how it is.”

While CID was investigating the allegations of rape brought forward by Ramirez, Hughes committed another rape at Fort Bliss. In the summer of 2017, Hughes admitted as part of his plea agreement, he violently raped his then-girlfriend on the base. However, he avoided being charged for telling his then-girlfriend not to speak to CID, and for intentionally cutting the woman with a broken bottle.

Later in 2017, while he was still at Fort Bliss, the Army allowed Hughes to take custody of his then 14-year-old daughter. According to her mother, Chayla Madsen, Hughes had not been involved in the girl’s life, and she was not aware of the rape allegations swirling in the background. The teenager too would eventually be a victim of Hughes.

Army sexual harassment awareness; serial rapist
Brig. Gen. Michael Lalor, commander of US Army Medical Logistics Command, speaks during a kickoff event April 2, 2021, to mark a monthlong observance of Sexual Assault Awareness and Prevention Month at Fort Detrick, Md. US Army photo by Kathryn Ellis-Warfield, courtesy of DVIDS.

“I never had any idea something like this [investigation] was open, and obviously he did this to look like an upstanding single dad,” Madsen told the Army Times. “I didn’t know he was being investigated … and Fort Bliss just allowed him to move a child — she was 14 — in with him and move on base.”

Hughes then transferred to Fort Dix, New Jersey. It wasn’t long before he was once again accused of rape. On March 25, 2020, Hughes allegedly gave his daughter sleeping medication and raped her. Hughes’ plea agreement did not admit to that charge, but he did admit to sexual abuse and assault of a child.

“He was taking a plea deal, so he wanted to plead to get the minimum amount of years,” said Lesley Madsen, the now 17-year-old daughter who asked, with her mother’s approval, to be named in the Army Times article. “If I said no, then it would have been years of court. … It was the easiest way to give everyone that closure and just put him away before he did anything to anybody else.”

CID Rape Soldier
US Army Criminal Investigation Command (CID) Headquarters at Marine Corps Base Quantico, in Quantico, Va. Department of Defense photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

A bit of silver lining was that now Fort Dix CID agents were able to see the GOMOR in Hughes’ file, and in 2020 they began looking into Hughes.

“I got really lucky and I had a team [of CID agents] who cared a lot … because they found everybody else and they started adding it all up,” Lesley Madsen said. “It was just insane, because none of us even expected the extent of what he did.”

That CID inquiry ultimately resulted in criminal charges spanning more than a decade and involving five victims. A plea agreement whittled the charges down to the most recent incidents, including sexual abuse and assault of a child, as well as both 2017 rapes.

“Despite the persistent myth that suspected military sex offenders are prosecuted at a high rate, the reality is the chain of command rarely ever sends a suspect to court,” said former chief prosecutor of the Air Force Col. Don Christensen, who testified before Congress last month on the issue of sexual assault in the armed forces. “Right now, I’d say the military is uniquely bad at evaluating the strength of an allegation. In the vast majority of cases, leadership decides to do nothing.”

According to Christensen, service members who are suspects in cases of alleged sexual misconduct are charged in 49% of the cases, with roughly a third of those cases never making it to court. Instead, commanders often hand down nonjudicial punishments and other administrative actions.

“[The command] should be horrified their failure to hold the rapist accountable enabled a sex offender to perpetrate a crime wave against multiple victims,” said Christensen, who was not part of the case against Hughes, after looking at the trial results.

Read Next: Female Soldier Accuses 22 Troops of Sexual Assault at Fort Sill

James R. Webb
James R. Webb

James Webb served as a US Marine infantryman from 2005 to 2010, completing a combat tour in Iraq. He’s worked as a freelance writer and photojournalist covering US troops in Afghanistan, and Webb spent more than two years in the US Senate as a military legislative assistant and as the personal representative of a member on the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
Robert Heinlein: The Navy Vet Who Pioneered Sci-Fi

The dean of science fiction combined his experiences in the Navy with his knowledge as an aeronautical engineer to create genre-transforming novels.

January 27, 2023Mac Caltrider
Masih Alinejad
Feds: Brooklyn Cops Foil Brazen Iranian Plot to Murder Masih Alinejad

Three men reputedly linked to Eastern European mobsters and Iranian intelligence operatives have been arrested.

January 27, 2023Carl Prine
FILE - Ukrainian soldiers on captured Russian tanks T-72 hold military training close to the Ukraine-Belarus border near Chernihiv, Ukraine, Friday, Oct. 28, 2022. The West's move to send tanks to Ukraine was greeted enthusiastically from Kyiv, Berlin and Washington. But Moscow seemed to shrug. The Kremlin has warned the West that supplying tanks would be a dangerous escalation of the conflict and denounced the decision. AP photo by Aleksandr Shulman, File.
Russia Responds to Ukraine’s ‘Tanksgiving’ With Missile and Drone Strikes

Hours after the US and Germany agreed to send battle tanks to Ukraine, Russia launched missile and drone strikes at targets across the country.

January 26, 2023Nolan Peterson
Marine Corps Dedicates First New Base in 7 Decades

For the first time in seven decades, the US Marine Corps is building a new base.

January 26, 2023Carl Prine
US Sending Nearly a Battalion of Abrams Tanks to Ukraine

The US will send 31 Abrams tanks to Ukraine after months of uncertainty.

January 26, 2023Associated Press
The damaged tug Mark E. Kuebler grounded near Corpus Christi, Texas, on Sunday, Jan. 22, 2023. A large gash is visible just above the waterline. Photos courtesy of Boatswain’s Mate 2nd Class Merrit Carter. Composite by Kenna Lee/Coffee or Die Magazine.
Coast Guard Coxswain Emphasizes Having Clear Head During Tugboat Response

One of the world’s most innovative tugboats remains beached on a Texas sandbar, after apparently getting sucked under a massive oil tanker and mauled by its propeller.

January 26, 2023Noelle Wiehe
Coffee Or Die Photo
The ‘Tallinn Pledge’ for Ukraine: NATO V2.0?

Representatives from nine NATO countries gathered in Estonia and pledged more military aid for Ukraine.

January 20, 2023Nolan Peterson
Coffee Or Die Photo
Triple Seven Expedition
DISPATCH: With Celebratory Jump in Florida, Triple 7 Expedition Is a Wrap

The Triple 7 Expedition's team of nine vets wrapped up its breakneck skydiving expedition with a final, celebratory jump in Florida on Wednesday, Jan. 18.

January 20, 2023Jenna Biter
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved