New Podcast Reveals How ‘Band of Brothers’ Soldiers Helped Filmmakers Get Story Right

September 15, 2021Mac Caltrider
band of brothers

Band of Brothers was the first of three miniseries about WWII from Spielberg and Hanks. Screenshot from YouTube.

On Sept. 9, 2021, HBO released a 12-part podcast event marking the 20th anniversary of the network’s groundbreaking miniseries Band of Brothers. The show followed the men of Easy Company from D-Day to the end of World War II in Europe and set a new standard for war dramas. The new podcast, hosted by Roger Bennett, features directors, producers, and cast members dissecting the 10-episode story based on Stephen E. Ambrose’s book of the same name. 

Co-creator, producer, and director Tom Hanks joined the podcast’s prologue and revealed some previously unknown hurdles the filmmakers encountered while getting the show off the ground — most notably, harsh criticism from World War II legend Maj. Dick Winters and some of the other veterans of Easy Company.

band of brothers
Filmmakers Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg went to great lengths to tell the story of Easy Company accurately. Screenshot from YouTube.

Before the series moved into post-production, some of the initial footage was screened for Winters at his home in Pennsylvania. Hanks recounts during the podcast how the producers expected Winters to be delighted with what he saw. After all, the series was given an immense budget of $125 million (the highest budget for a TV show up to that point), and both Hanks and Steven Spielberg were determined to bring an unprecedented level of authenticity to the show. 

However, according to Hanks, Winters was less than pleased. The World War II veteran confessed the show had gotten the historical details correct when it came to weapons, uniforms, and lingo, but he felt it was wrong in its portrayal of the famed paratroopers. 

Band of brothers
Damian Lewis as World War II legend Maj. Dick Winters. Screenshot from Band of Brothers.

“The problem is you have us looking like we don’t know what we’re doing,” Hanks recalled Winters saying. “Tom, we knew what we were doing. We knew where we were. We knew what needed to get done. You have it looking like we haven’t even read the map correctly!” 

Winters was speaking about the show’s depiction of the assault on Brécourt Manor, an action that earned him the Distinguished Service Cross and is still taught at the US Military Academy at West Point as an example of effective small-unit tactics. The original plan for the episode was to stress the uncertainty the paratroopers faced during the invasion of Normandy, but apparently the editors overdid it. Hanks explained during the podcast that the producers had no ego about the show and welcomed all feedback from the veterans themselves.

“Our job here is not to screw up the lives of the subject matter. Our job is not to discern for ourselves what you went through but to find out what happened and try and dramatize that and make it real on screen,” Hanks recalled saying to Winters. 

Following the constructive feedback, producers altered their approach to reflect the paratroopers’ competence and professionalism. But Winters was not the only veteran concerned with how the men of Easy Company were portrayed. 

The Band of Brothers producers set out to depict the violence of war realistically, which is why they chose to sign with HBO rather than another network. Ambrose only agreed to hand his work over to Hanks and Spielberg because of their previous collaboration on Saving Private Ryan and that film’s unapologetic depiction of graphic war violence. Beyond realistically portraying the physical toll combat takes on the human body, the show’s producers sought to depict the mental cost as well, most notably through the character of Lt. Buck Compton.

band of brothers
Dick Winters reflects on his service in interview footage at the end of Band of Brothers. Screenshot from YouTube.

When Compton met with Neal McDonough — the actor who played him — he revealed an inaccuracy in the book. Ambrose wrote that Compton was simply wounded during the Battle of the Bulge and evacuated to a hospital. The truth was markedly different.

“I wasn’t wounded in the Bulge. I cracked up … Look, I had been shot in the ass during Market Garden, and I was in the hospital lying on my belly with a bleeding butt. I was surrounded by guys who’d had their legs blown off, their genitals blown off, their heads barely held together with tape and catgut. I felt like a fool. When I was brought back [to the front] I couldn’t take it, so I cracked up. I had a nervous breakdown,” Compton told McDonough.

Buck Compton’s mental breakdown was left out of the Band of Brothers book at the request of some of his comrades. Screenshot from YouTube.

According to Hanks, other Easy Company veterans had apparently taken issue with that information being shared and insisted Ambrose take it out of the book prior to being published. Hanks then had to get permission directly from Compton to include the true version of his struggle in the miniseries. 

Band of Brothers premiered Sept. 9, 2001. The standout drama took on a whole new meaning when, two days later, the US was attacked by al Qaeda. The ensuing wave of patriotism carried the show to unexpected heights and earned six Emmys. On the 20th anniversary of both 9/11 and the show’s premiere, the 12-part podcast is a timely and revealing reflection on both American heroes and the iconic TV series. 

Read Next: Spielberg, Hanks Begin Work on 3rd World War II Series: ‘Masters of the Air’

Mac Caltrider
Mac Caltrider

Mac Caltrider is a senior staff writer for Coffee or Die Magazine. He served in the US Marine Corps and is a former police officer. Caltrider earned his bachelor’s degree in history and now reads anything he can get his hands on. He is also the creator of Pipes & Pages, a site intended to increase readership among enlisted troops. Caltrider spends most of his time reading, writing, and waging a one-man war against premature hair loss.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
How the Bazooka Gained Infamy as a Tank-Buster

Named after a musical instrument, the Bazooka proved to be a highly effective weapon for American troops, including one maverick pilot, throughout multiple wars.

Secretary of the Air Force Frank Kendall (center) delivers testimony during a House Appropriations Committee hearing in the Capitol Building, Washington, D.C.
Home to Glenn, Armstrong, Wrights Perfect Spot for Space Command HQ, Ohio Lawmakers Say

Ohio lawmakers pitch their state as the new location for Space Command headquarters.

Soflete: How This Veteran-Led Company is Changing Military Fitness Culture

In 2014, Soflete’s co-founders saw workout overkill hurting their peers as they prepared for selecti...

glock 19
Glock 19: Origin Story of a Legendary Pistol

Get to know the Glock 19 — how it works, who uses it, and why it’s one of the most popular handguns in the US.

afghan soldier asylum
Afghan Soldier Who Helped US Weathers Injuries, Uncertainty in Asylum Bid

Afghan soldier who assisted the U.S. now faces uncertainty in bid for asylum.

The Dirty Dozen
‘The Dirty Dozen’: Meet D-Day’s Real Rogue Commandos

The Dirty Dozen was based on a real team of rule-breaking elite paratroopers who jumped into France ahead of D-Day.

d-day 79th anniversary
Normandy Marks D-Day's 79th Anniversary, Honors World War II Veterans

This year's D-Day tribute to the young soldiers who died in Normandy is not only a chance to honor t...

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved