Intel

Battle of Puebla: The (True) Story Behind Cinco de Mayo

May 5, 2019Kevin Knodell
Coffee or Die Photo

Most Americans recognize Cinco de Mayo by drinking margaritas and eating tacos. Today, it’s a celebration of Mexican culture — and it’s a much bigger deal in America than in Mexico. Though many Americans mistake Cinco de Mayo for Mexico’s independence day (which is September 16), it’s actually a military holiday. It celebrates the day that a group of outgunned Mexican troops took on a much larger and better equipped French force and won.


However, the legacy of the Battle of Puebla is more than a mere military engagement — the battle and its aftermath offer a glimpse into the inextricably linked history of the United States and Mexico. It’s a story of war, slavery, sacrifice, and the struggle for freedom and democracy.


French, Spanish, and British troops invaded Mexico in 1861 after newly elected Mexican President Benito Juarez put a moratorium on debt repayments to Europe. However, France’s Napoleon III had more ambitious aims. The way he saw it, if he could capture Mexico, he would make it the first colony in what he hoped would be a new French stronghold in the Americas. With the Americans embroiled in the Civil War, they wouldn’t be in a position to stop him.


The 26th president of Mexico, Benito Juárez campaigned for equal rights for indigenous people and fought to reduce the influence of the Catholic Church in politics. Juárez was president during the Battle of Puebla and is honored in Mexico with Benito Juárez Day on March 21, his birthday.

He also saw the potential to support the Confederacy in their fight against the Union. Slavery allowed the Confederacy to harvest and sell cotton and tobacco at low prices to European markets, but a Union blockade had slowed those exports and made them increasingly rare in Europe. Napoleon believed that he could support the Confederacy with modern artillery and weapons in return for their crops. The British and the Spanish cut deals with Juarez, but Napoleon’s forces kept pressing on.


The Mexican troops fighting back were under the command of General Ignacio Zaragoza. As a young man, the Texas-born Zaragoza had risen in the ranks of an army of volunteers that in 1855 defeated Mexican dictator Santa Anna and led to the re-establishment of a constitutionally democratic government in Mexico. He served in Juarez’s cabinet as Secretary of War but resigned to return to the field to fight the European invaders.


The French routed Zaragoza’s forces at Acultzingo on April 28, 1862, forcing him to withdraw. But he knew that he could lay a trap for them in Puebla. The town was already heavily fortified — to its north, forts Loreto and Guadalupe stood on opposite hilltops. Zaragoza had his men dig a trench that joined the two forts via a saddle in the hills.


Ignacio Zaragoza.

General Charles de Lorencez, the French commander, was under the impression that the town’s occupants were friendly to the French and would overthrow the Mexican garrison when his men arrived.


Lorencez decided to attack Puebla from the north, just as Zaragoza predicted he would. During numerous failed attempts to assault the city, his troops ran out of munitions for their artillery. As Lorencez’s men retreated from their final assault, Zaragoza had his cavalry attack them from both sides while troops concealed along the road flanked them. By the afternoon the daily rains had turned the battlefield into slippery mud.


Lorencez regrouped, counting 462 of his men dead against only 83 of the Mexicans. He waited a couple of days, hoping to lure Zaragoza into the open — but he wouldn’t take the bait. Eventually, Lorencez withdrew his forces to Orizaba. The French army had suffered its first major defeat in five decades.


General Bazaine attacks the fort of San Xavier during the siege of Puebla, 29 March 1863. Painting by Jean-Adolphe Beaucé.

Not long after his historic victory, Zaragoza became stricken with a case of typhoid fever that swiftly killed him at age of 33. But news of the victory spread across the county, as well as north to the Mexican miners in California who had gone for the gold rush. Mexican-Americans were fighting on both sides of the Civil War, but in California, most Mexicans were staunch Union supporters. One of the first things Mexicans had done after winning independence from Spain was abolish slavery.


Soon after the victory at Puebla, Mexican-Americans in California and Nevada began forming Juntas Patrióticas —“Patriotic Assemblies” — to celebrate the victory at Puebla and what it meant for the Union cause. They held monthly rallies where they gave speeches praising Zaragoza and troops and denouncing the pro-slavery Confederates.


General Zaragoza’s Mexican army outside repels French forces during the Battle of Puebla on May 5, 1862. Painting by Patricio Ramos Ortega. National History Museum, Mexico City

French troops began a new advance in 1863, this time capturing Puebla and seizing Mexico City. Napoleon then installed Ferdinand Maximilian — the younger brother of Austrian Emperor Franz Joseph I — as Mexico’s new ruler. He became known as Maximilian I of Mexico. By that time, the U.S. Union Army had won several decisive victories, and the French essentially abandoned their effort to get involved in the U.S. Civil War.


Meanwhile, Juárez and his elected government fled the capital and became a government in exile. Several supporters, including Juarez’s wife, fled to the United States. Mexico’s first lady met with President Abraham Lincoln several times during her time in the country.


The Mexican resistance badly needed funds and weapons if it was to survive. In 1864, Juarez sent General Plácido de la Vega on a secret mission to California to meet with leading Mexican-American families to get backing for their effort to re-establish the government. While in California, Vega became the vice president of the Union Club of San Francisco and volunteered to work on Lincoln’s 1864 presidential reelection. The gambit paid off; funds from Mexican-American communities went south, along with donations from other sympathetic American communities.


Soon after the victory at Puebla, Mexican-Americans in California and Nevada began forming Juntas Patrióticas —“Patriotic Assemblies” — to celebrate the victory at Puebla and what it meant for the Union cause.


As both the Civil War and the French occupation of Mexico dragged on, members of the Juntas Patrióticas began paying dues to support the war efforts on both sides of the border. On Cinco de Mayo, Mexican-Americans held parades in which they carried both American and Mexican flags and sang songs in English and Spanish.


When the Confederacy finally surrendered, Lincoln’s government became more openly hostile to the French intervention in Mexico. Several Union army veterans began making their way to Mexico to fight on the side of the Mexican rebels — some as volunteers and others as soldiers of fortune.



After Lincoln’s assassination, President Andrew Johnson demanded the French withdraw from Mexico and imposed a naval blockade in February 1866. Not long after, U.S. Army troops started to “lose” gear “near” (or, according to some accounts, across) the border with Mexico. In General Philip Sheridan’s memoirs, he wrote that he had given arms and ammunition to Juárez’s forces, “which we left at convenient places on our side of the river to fall into their hands.”


By late 1866, the French forces began their withdrawal, and in 1867, Juarez’s forces routed the last of Maximilian’s troops.


Juarez’s troops captured and executed Maximilian.


Cinco de Mayo celebrations continued in Mexican communities in California and Nevada, and they have gradually spread to Chicano communities around the United States, morphing over time into the celebration we know today.


Kevin Knodell
Kevin Knodell

Kevin Knodell is a freelance journalist and author. His work has appeared at Foreign Policy, Playboy, Soldier of Fortune, and others. He’s the associate producer of the War College Podcast and a former contributing editor at Warisboring. He’s the co-author of the graphic novels The ‘Stan and Machete Squad, and he currently writes the Acts of Valor comic series for Naval History magazine.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
Military
Navy Releases First Photos of Chinese Balloon Recovery

In the newest images released by the Navy on Tuesday, sailors from Explosive Ordnance Disposal Group...

February 7, 2023Associated Press
Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin speaks at the Pentagon in Washington, Nov. 16, 2022. Lawyers for a group of Navy SEALS and other Navy personnel who oppose a COVID-19 vaccination requirement on religious grounds want a federal appeals court to keep alive their legal fight against the Biden administration. Congress voted to end the requirement in December 2022, but vaccine opponents note that commanders can still make decisions on how and whether to deploy unvaccinated troops, under a memo signed last month by Austin. AP photo by Susan Walsh, File.
Military
Vaccine Litigation Lingers After Lifting of Military Mandate

Lawyers for a group of Navy SEALS and other Navy personnel who refuse to be vaccinated for religious...

February 7, 2023Associated Press
Armed Forces Service Medal
Military
Who Earns the Armed Forces Service Medal?

The Department of Defense honors heroism in combat in many ways, but there is also an award — the Ar...

February 7, 2023Noelle Wiehe
Soldiers carry the coffin of Eduard Strauss, a Ukrainian serviceman who died in combat on Jan. 17 in Bakhmut, during a farewell ceremony in Kyiv, Ukraine, Monday, Feb. 6, 2023. AP photo by Daniel Cole.
Intel
Russian Forces Keep Up Pressue As Ukraine Anniversary Nears

Russian forces are keeping Ukrainian troops tied down with attacks in the eastern Donbas region as M...

February 7, 2023Associated Press
Chinese spy balloon
Military
Blown to Bits! Chinese Spy Balloon Blasted, Plummets Into Sea

The US Air Force downed the Chinese balloon that's been soaring over the US.

February 4, 2023Carl Prine
germany, european union, ukraine gas reserves
Intel
Ukraine Wants To Store Europe’s Strategic Gas Reserves

Ukraine maintains 12 underground gas storage facilities with a total capacity of about 31 billion cu...

February 3, 2023Nolan Peterson
Dear John letter
History
‘Dear John Letters’ — A History of Wartime Breakups

The dreaded Dear John: the wartime breakup notice that took weeks to arrive in the mail.

February 3, 2023Matt Fratus
National Defense Service Medal
Military
A Brief History of the National Defense Service Medal

First issued at the end of the Korean War, the National Defense Service Medal has been awarded durin...

February 2, 2023Jenna Biter
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved