How a Depleted Utah Silver Mine Almost Started a War With England

October 18, 2021Lauren Coontz
emma mine

Emma Mine’s town district was eventually destroyed by an avalanche in 1885. Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

Local rumor has it that the Emma Silver Mine in Utah’s Little Cottonwood Canyon almost started a war with England in the 1870s. Located near the Alta Ski Area (of 2002 Winter Olympics fame), the Emma Mine consists of a large tunnel bored into the granite rock face of a remote Utah canyon.

After miners tapped out the central silver vein, knowing full well that Emma Mine was empty, an American senator and businessman attempted to sell off their shares in the project to hapless British investors.

US Minister to England Robert C. Schenck, an Ohio Republican, partnered with Trenor W. Park, one of the mine’s owners, to organize the scheme. The mine’s other owners included James Lyon as well as Horace Henry Baxter, a New York business promoter and a Civil War hero from Vermont. 

emma mine
Little Cottonwood Canyon, a U-shaped canyon overlooking the Salt Lake Valley, is home to award-winning Alta ski resort. Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

Park and Schenck allegedly paid Yale chemistry professor Benjamin Silliman some $50,000 to write a report claiming that the Emma Mine was “one of the great mines of the world” and had “great value.” The mine produced $2 million worth of silver in the summer of 1871. However, the site was an “accidental deposit, or ‘pocket,’ [and] was not a true fissure vein,” according to an 1876 article from The New York Times

By the time Park and Schenck schemed to sell Emma Mine, there was very little silver left inside the cavern. Moreover, the site was already difficult to manage because of the large amount of water that had permeated the granite. In short, Schenck and Park knew they were never going to get more out of the lode, and selling the place was nothing short of a scam.

silver senator
William Stewart, known as the “Silver Senator,” had several mining holdings throughout Utah, California, and Nevada.

Schenck and Park cut Lyon out of the sale of the mine. For his part, Lyon sued, claiming that Park and Schenck had bribed his lawyer, William Stewart — a Nevada senator — with stock from the defunct mine. In Lyon’s court case, Schenck and Park also conspired to use stocks to buy and sway the lawsuit’s jury.

Lyon likely lost his case in Utah because his lawyer, Stewart, later testified against Schenck and Park. Technically, the mine sale was legal, but Schenck and Park deliberately misrepresented the worth of the silver the site held.

Albert Grant, “one of the leading and most detested London financial wizards of the last half of the nineteenth century,” according to one source, promoted the sale of Emma Mine stock in the London financial markets. Although Grant sold off his stake in the mine, the worth of those shares plummeted to near zero once authorities revealed that the Emma Mine was depleted and, therefore, effectively worthless.

Robert Schenck fought during the Civil War, ranking up to major general. Schenck became the Minister of Trade to the United Kingdom in 1871. Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

Ruffled by the potential geopolitical consequences, Congress conducted an inquiry into the matter. Because of their parts in the scandal, Schenck and Stewart became public pariahs. Stewart was already infamous — because of his extensive mine ownership throughout the West, his nickname was the “silver senator.” Thus, Stewart did not seek reelection after the Emma Mine affair became public, and he tendered his resignation to President Ulysses S. Grant.

London was severely displeased by the whole incident and threatened an investigation. Consequently, rumors began to spread that the scandal could spark an armed conflict. In any case, British threats to sue the US on behalf of the duped Emma Mine shareholders never materialized. Ultimately, the scandal only amounted to a war of words — and a historic embarrassment for the United States. 

Today, the Emma Mine site’s only useful purpose is to provide the nearby city of Alta with a reliable source of fresh water.

Read Next: Coffee in Combat: How a Cup of Joe Inspires America’s Warfighters

Lauren Coontz
Lauren Coontz

Lauren Coontz is a former staff writer for Coffee or Die Magazine. Beaches are preferred, but Lauren calls the Rocky Mountains of Utah home. You can usually find her in an art museum, at an archaeology site, or checking out local nightlife like drag shows and cocktail bars (gin is key). A student of history, Lauren is an Army veteran who worked all over the world and loves to travel to see the old stuff the history books only give a sentence to. She likes medium roast coffee and sometimes, like a sinner, adds sweet cream to it.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
‘The Gift’ Explores the Life and Legacy of Medal of Honor Recipient Jason Dunham

"The Gift" tells the story of the first Marine to receive the Medal of Honor after the Vietnam War. ...

March 24, 2023Mac Caltrider
uss milius
US Denies Chinese Claim It Drove Away American Destroyer

The U.S. Navy's 7th Fleet said that a statement from China's Southern Theatre Command that it had fo...

March 23, 2023Associated Press
The Speed Project: Vet Team To Run in Lawless, Invite-Only Ultramarathon

For the first time, a team of (mostly) US veterans and active-duty service members will run in The S...

March 23, 2023Jenna Biter
uranium-based ammo ammunition Ukraine UK depleted uranium
A Look At the Uranium-Based Ammo the UK Will Send to Ukraine

The British defense ministry on Monday confirmed it would provide Ukraine with armor-piercing rounds containing depleted uranium.

March 23, 2023Associated Press
Zaporizhzhia Ukraine Russia
Ukraine: Russia Hits Apartments and Dorm, Killing Civilians

“Russia is shelling the city with bestial savagery,” President Volodymyr Zelenskyy wrote in a Telegr...

March 22, 2023Associated Press
cold brew coffee soda float
The Bitter Barista's Cold Brew Coffee Soda Float

Today, we combine the best of both worlds with this indulgent recipe, smashing together our love of coffee and ice cream with a cold brew coffee soda float!

March 21, 2023Heather Lynn
abrams tanks ukraine
US Speeds Up Abrams Tank Delivery to Ukraine War Zone

The original plan was to send Ukraine 31 of the newer M1A2 Abrams, which could have taken a year or ...

March 21, 2023Associated Press
Coffee Or Die Photo
US: War Crimes on All Sides in Ethiopia's Tigray Conflict

The Biden administration announced Monday that it has determined all sides in the brutal conflict in Ethiopia’s northern Tigray region committed war crimes and crimes against humanity.

March 20, 2023Associated Press
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved