First Responders

Ida in New York: Could a ‘Fifth Firefighter’ Have Saved More Lives?

September 8, 2021Joshua Skovlund
As the remnants of Hurricane Ida dumped rain on the Bronx, firefighters found about 70 cars stalled, with the west wall of the Major Deegan Expressway acting like a waterfall. In a Sept. 1 rescue that took nearly two hours, firefighters evacuated 52 people. Photo courtesy of the New York City Fire Department.

As the remnants of Hurricane Ida dumped rain on the Bronx, firefighters found about 70 cars stalled, with the west wall of the Major Deegan Expressway acting like a waterfall. In a Sept. 1 rescue that took nearly two hours, firefighters evacuated 52 people. Photo courtesy of the New York City Fire Department.

When a massive storm triggered flash floods across New York Sept. 1, only 20 of the city’s 193 engine companies put more than four firefighters on a truck.

The “fifth fireman” was standard through the 1970s, but penny-pinching administrations began whittling the number down. By the end of Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s administration, City Hall had ordered four firefighters to each engine.

The union representing the city’s firefighters — the Uniformed Firefighters Association of Greater New York — was battling lame-duck Mayor Bill de Blasio for that extra staffer on each truck when a monster storm walloped the city Sept. 1.

Remnants of Hurricane Ida merged with a super-saturated front, creating a freak cyclone that pummeled Central Park with 3 inches of rain in just an hour — and over 7 inches in all.

One of the New York City Fire Department’s finest searches a vehicle caught up in the flooding that took over the streets of NYC Sept. 1, 2021, into Sept. 2. Photo courtesy of the Uniformed Firefighters Association of Greater New York/Twitter.

Sewers backed up, turning streets into raging rapids. Basement apartments flooded. Gushing water submerged subways. When the clouds dissipated, 13 New Yorkers were dead.

Could an extra firefighter on each engine have saved more lives?

“That’s impossible to say,” Uniformed Firefighters Association of Greater New York president Andrew Ansbro told Coffee or Die Magazine Tuesday. “A lot of people were found in houses where no calls were even made.

“So there’s no way to say that we would have been somewhere we were never called to.”

De Blasio’s staffers didn’t respond to Coffee or Die‘s requests for comment.

But in the past, city officials blamed the lack of a fifth firefighter on chronic absenteeism, often caused by personnel on medical leave. 

The union countered by saying many of those on “sickouts” suffered from 9/11-related illnesses and injuries that should’ve led to disability cases.

To Ansbro, Ida is a wake-up call reminding City Hall that it’s time to return the fifth firefighter to duty.

“As long as we hire the staffing, we can put them in service — and when you’re expecting a hurricane or some kind of tropical storm, you would expect to have a very high call volume,” Ansbro said.

fifth firefighter
A fifth fighter on every engine is something New York City hasn’t seen since the 1980s. Photo by Robert Harkness, courtesy of Unsplash.

The city will spend about $2.2 billion next year to support 10,945 uniform positions and 6,441 civilian positions.

To help prevent another Ida-sized calamity, Ansbro believes the city would need to hire about 300 more firefighters. 

“It’s a money issue, and they chose not to,” Ansbro said of the city that he feels “rolls the dice” before every disaster and that came up short on Ida.

At the very least, the union wants City Hall to automatically hike the number of firefighters available for potentially catastrophic storms, even if that means paying overtime.

“It has been a constant call of the union that the staffing levels be changed automatically when the weather forecast predicts extreme weather, and unfortunately, it comes down to a human decision, and human error plays a part,” Ansbro said. 

“People don’t schedule when they’re going to have a fire,” he added. “It happens. Disasters happen, and you have to have the staffing there when it happens.”

Read Next: New York Firefighters Bravely Battled Ida, but Did Understaffing Hamper Rescues?

Joshua Skovlund
Joshua Skovlund

Joshua Skovlund has covered the 75th anniversary of D-Day in France, multinational military exercises in Germany, and civil unrest during the 2020 riots in Minneapolis that followed the death of George Floyd. Born and raised in small-town South Dakota, he grew up playing football and soccer before serving as a forward observer in the US Army. After leaving the service, he earned his CrossFit Level 1 certificate and worked as a personal trainer while earning his paramedic license. He went on to work in paramedicine for more than five years, much of that time in the North Minneapolis area, before transitioning to a career in multimedia journalism. Joshua is married with two children. His creative outlets include Skovlund Photography and Concentrated Emotion, where he publishes poetry focused on his life experiences.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
Military Moves To Cut Suicides, But Defers Action on Guns

In a memo released Thursday, Austin called for the establishment of a suicide prevention working gro...

March 17, 2023Associated Press
us military drills japan-south korea
US, Partners Stage Military Drills Amid Japan-South Korea Talks

The Sea Dragon 23 exercises that started on Wednesday will culminate in more than 270 hours of in-fl...

March 17, 2023Associated Press
leo jenkins a word like god
‘A Word Like God’: New Book From Army Ranger Leo Jenkins

In his latest poetry collection, Ranger-turned-writer Leo Jenkins turns away from war to explore cosmic themes of faith, fatherhood, and art.

March 16, 2023Mac Caltrider
us drone
Pentagon Video Shows Russian Jet Dumping Fuel on US Drone

The Pentagon on Thursday released video of what it said was a Russian fighter jet dumping fuel on a ...

March 16, 2023Associated Press
10th Mountain Division
‘Climb to Glory’ — A History of the US Army’s 10th Mountain Division

From the mountains of Italy to the mountains of Afghanistan, the US Army’s 10th Mountain Division built its legendary reputation by fighting in some of the most inhospitable places in the world.

March 16, 2023Matt Fratus
iraq invasion 20 years later
Why US Troops Remain in Iraq 20 Years After 'Shock and Awe'

The roughly 2,500 U.S. troops are scattered around the country, largely in military installations in Baghdad and in the north.

March 15, 2023Associated Press
Ohio train derailment
First Responders
BRCC Donates Coffee to Towns Ravaged by Train Wreck and Historic Storms

Americans living in East Palestine, Ohio, and central Oklahoma are recovering from February disaster...

March 15, 2023Jenna Biter
Coffee Or Die Photo
DOD Official Says Sub Agreement Will Help Guarantee Free, Open Indo-Pacific

Mara E. Karlin, performing the duties of deputy undersecretary of defense for policy, said the agree...

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved