First Responders

Joe Exotic, PT Barnum, America’s Shabby Cat Shows, and the Feds Who Police Them

November 19, 2021Coffee or Die
“Lion Tamer,” depicting a lion  tamer in a cage with two lions, a lioness, and two tigers. A chromolithographic image
by Gibson & Co. (Cincinnati, Ohio), c1873.  Library of Congress image.

“Lion Tamer,” depicting a lion tamer in a cage with two lions, a lioness, and two tigers. A chromolithographic image by Gibson & Co. (Cincinnati, Ohio), c1873. Library of Congress image.

“I am never gonna financially recover from this,” grumbles Joe Exotic, the subject of Netflix’s “Tiger King” documentary series.

Joe Exotic, whose real name is Joseph Maldonado-Passage, blithely utters the line after one of his employees has been brutally mauled by a tiger, making him seem comically indifferent to the man’s suffering.

This lack of compassion isn’t unique to Joe Exotic. As a self-proclaimed “gun-toting gay redneck” and the former operator of a shabby wildlife park, he may seem like the furthest thing from a cutthroat capitalist.

But I study 19th-century showmen like P.T. Barnum, and as I rewatched season one of “Tiger King” to prepare for the new season, I was struck by the similarities between my research subjects and the larger-than-life world of Joe Exotic.

These impresarios also had money on their minds. And like Joe Exotic and the other flamboyant big-cat aficionados of “Tiger King,” they weren’t strangers to fierce competition, threats and bizarre drama.

Joe Exotic
“Bostock’s trained lions,” a photograph showing lion tamer Frank C. Bostock sitting in a chair with newspaper surrounded by 13 lions, c1903. Library of Congress photograph.

Lying about lions

In “Tiger King,” viewers learn that Joe Exotic is part of a larger network of big cat exhibitors who regularly trade and sell animals to one another, often in violation of the Endangered Species Act.

The groups include characters such as Bhagavan “Doc” Antle, the elephant-riding, polyamorous owner of Myrtle Beach Safari wildlife park, who is currently under indictment for felony wildlife trafficking. There’s also Jeff Lowe, who purchased Joe Exotic’s zoo and is also facing charges in Las Vegas related to possessing exotic animals without permits. Carole Baskin, Joe Exotic’s archnemesis, aims to take down this network of breeders and traffickers by pushing to ban the private possession of big cats.

In the 19th century, when the total number of exotic animals in the country was much lower, big cat exhibitors didn’t have to smuggle cubs. In fact, back then, the big cat trade network actually included legitimate scientific institutions.

In 1895, James A. Bailey of the Barnum & Bailey circus was involved in a dispute with Frank Baker of the Smithsonian National Zoo over a trade involving two lions.

Joe Exotic
“Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus. The incomparable Alfred Court, master trainer / G.H.” Circus poster showing Alfred Court with a variety of trained animals, including lions, tigers, and bears.” This poster was created ca. 1941. Library of Congress image.

From Baker’s telegrams to Bailey, it’s clear that Baker felt the showman scammed him. When the circus representative arrived at the Smithsonian with the feline cargo, Baker “was very much surprised to find that he did not bring with him the lion which [Bailey] agreed to let me have but a smaller one.” Baker felt duped and demanded they trade back, but Bailey refused, accusing Baker of giving him an inferior lion.

Despite continued demands from Baker, Bailey didn’t budge, and in the last letter of their exchange, an exasperated Baker folded – but not before writing in a delightfully passive-aggressive, 19th-century manner that “I agree to accept the exchange of lions notwithstanding the fact that you have endeavored to force it upon me without my consent.”

Joe Exotic
“Adjie and her trained lions,” a photograph showing the lion-tamer Adjie, holding whip, sitting in cage next to large yawning lion, in 1897. Library of Congress image.

Education, entertainment or exploitation?

The circus’s relationship with the Smithsonian hints at another parallel between 19th-century circuses and today’s wildlife exhibitions: Both attempt to blur the line between entertainment and education.

By claiming that they are not mere entertainment, but opportunities for enlightenment, animal exhibitors then and now have sought to legitimize their business and distance themselves from allegations of animal abuse.

Joe Exotic, “Doc” Antle and Carole Baskin all claim in “Tiger King” that their work is truly about educating the public about endangered species – that, deep down, their primary motivation is to promote conservation efforts. They all attempt, with varying success, to use the veneer of education to distance themselves from stereotypes that their roadside zoos are seedy and rife with abuse.

In the increasingly capitalist society of the late-19th century, promoters like P.T. Barnum wanted the circus to appeal to as many customers as possible. So he and his peers began emphasizing the educational potential of their shows. This was not merely a display of animals doing tricks, they’d insist; this was, as an advertisement for Barnum & Bailey’s circus proclaimed, “better than a college for rare knowledge.”

Back in the day, Barnum even went so far as to call his animal keepers “professors,” a title eerily similar to that of the questionable “Doc” Antle.

Joe Exotic
Untitled image of an animal keeper feeding raw meat to lions in a circus cage as spectators watch, created in Detroit, Mich., by the Calvert Litho. Co., c1891. Library of Congress image.

Petty feuds and frauds

Joe Exotic was a traveling showman for a while, taking a small exhibition of tigers on tours of local shopping malls and other small venues. Amusingly, Exotic called this venture Big Cat Rescue Entertainment, an obvious reference to rival Baskin’s organization, Big Cat Rescue Corporation.

The petty move on Exotic’s part is once again something that could have come from a Gilded Age showman’s playbook.

Nineteenth-century entertainment impresarios often published notices in trade papers warning others to be on the lookout for fraudulent companies masquerading under the name of another well-established show, such as when the popular Sells Bros. Circus took the Sells-Floto Circus to court over the latter’s use of the Sells name, despite having no owner by that name.

In one case, a rival circus put together an entire pamphlet full of insults directed at Bailey, with lines like “J.A. Bailey, you are a thoroughly exposed, convicted, baffled, beaten, desperate and crazy fraud.”

Joe Exotic
“Walter L. Main 3 ring trained wild animal shows,” a poster showing woman with six tigers. It was created by Milwaukee : Riverside Printing Co., between 1860 and 1930. Library of Congress image.

And in an insult that sounds like it could have come straight from Exotic’s lips, the pamphlet added that even Bailey’s “performing lions are cringing, crawling, sneaking frauds.”

Had these men had access to Facebook Live, I can only imagine the content they’d create.

While I have yet to come across any archival information suggesting my research subjects were involved in any murder-for-hire plots – Exotic is currently serving a 22-year prison sentence for trying to have Baskin killed – I have seen rival companies being accused of literally burning bridges to hamper their competitors.

Joe Exotic
Circus poster showing tiger and woman on horseback published in Cincinnati and New York by Strobridge Litho. Co., c1899. Library of Congress image.

Describing the competition between shows as “opposition warfare,” W.C. Coup, a business partner of P.T. Barnum’s, once wrote that he suspected a rival circus of destroying a bridge to prevent their train from arriving on time for their gig. Although he had no proof, Coup wrote that he “knew [his competitors] were driven to desperation and were capable of resorting to any such outrage.”

That’s just a small sampling of the entertaining and sordid anecdotes that can be found in archives devoted to Gilded Age show business.

Perhaps it’s time for the circus to get the Netflix treatment.

“The lion queen,” a printed poster showing a woman lion-tamer in a cage with several lions and tigers., by Gibson & Co. (Cincinnati, Ohio), c1874. Library of Congress image.

This story appeared first in The Conversation on Nov. 18, 2021. The Conversation is a community of more than 135,400 academics and researchers from 4,192 institutions. 

Read next:   Operation Kuluna – Federal Sting Targets Traffickers Smuggling Endangered Animals

Coffee or Die
Coffee or Die

Coffee or Die is Black Rifle Coffee Company’s online lifestyle magazine. Launched in June 2018, the magazine covers a variety of topics that generally focus on the people, places, or things that are interesting, entertaining, or informative to America’s coffee drinkers — often going to dangerous or austere locations to report those stories.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
9 Killed In Army Black Hawk Helicopter Crash In Kentucky

Nondice Thurman, a spokesperson for Fort Campbell, said Thursday morning that the deaths happened the previous night in southwestern Kentucky during a routine training mission.

March 30, 2023Associated Press
richard stayskal act military medical malpractice
DOD Denies Most Stayskal Act Malpractice Claims

Master Sgt. Richard Stayskal was diagnosed with lung cancer long after military doctors missed a tum...

March 29, 2023Maggie BenZvi
ukraine lessons learned
Opinion & Essay
Nolan Peterson: Lessons From Russia's Invasion of Ukraine

After living in and reporting from Ukraine the last nine years, conflict journalist Nolan Peterson h...

March 28, 2023Nolan Peterson
ukrainian wounded soldiers
‘On Tour In Hell’: Wounded Ukrainian Soldiers Evacuated

With bandaged heads and splinted limbs, the wounded soldiers are stretchered into the waiting medica...

March 27, 2023Associated Press
US oil mission
US Launches Airstrikes in Syria After Drone Kills US Worker

While it’s not the first time the U.S. and Iran have traded airstrikes in Syria, the attack and the ...

March 24, 2023Associated Press
The Gift jason dunham
‘The Gift’ Explores the Life and Legacy of Medal of Honor Recipient Jason Dunham

"The Gift" tells the story of the first Marine to receive the Medal of Honor after the Vietnam War. ...

March 24, 2023Mac Caltrider
uss milius
US Denies Chinese Claim It Drove Away American Destroyer

The U.S. Navy's 7th Fleet said that a statement from China's Southern Theatre Command that it had fo...

March 23, 2023Associated Press
The Speed Project: Vet Team To Run in Lawless, Invite-Only Ultramarathon

For the first time, a team of (mostly) US veterans and active-duty service members will run in The S...

March 23, 2023Jenna Biter
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved