Medical Exemptions but None for Religion? Judge Calls Out COVID-19 Vaccine Double Standard

February 8, 2022Maggie BenZvi

The commanding officer of a Naval guided-missile destroyer just scored a big win in his fight against the military’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate. US Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Ryan M. Breeden.

A US district judge appears to have noticed what advocates for religious accommodation have been saying for weeks: Since the military has shown a willingness to grant medical exemptions to the COVID-19 vaccine mandate, why have only three religious exemptions been granted out of more than 10,000 applications?

“One struggles to imagine a wholesome and lawful explanation for the results evidenced in this record,” Judge Steven Merryday of the US District Court for the Middle District of Florida wrote in an order filed Wednesday, Feb. 2. “The military is well aware of the frailty of their arguments in defense of their practices.”

In his order, Merryday noted the vast gulf between medical exemptions approved by the military and the military’s near-total rejection of religious exemption applications. The numbers presented to the judge at the time of his ruling were that the Navy had granted 270 medical exemptions and zero religious exemptions, while the Marines had granted 234 medical exemptions and allowed three religious exemptions.

Both the Army and Air Force have also publicly said they have not granted any religious exemptions.

US District Court Middle District of Florida
The decision in the US District Court’s Middle District of Florida featured harsh words from Judge Steven Merryday, who called the military’s arguments “frail.” Image from Twitter.

Merryday’s strong words came as part of a decision in an ongoing suit in which two military plaintiffs have sued for religious accommodations. Merryday granted a week of injunctive relief to the two plaintiffs and indicated that the service members were “very likely” to prevail in their claim.

Lawyers for the plaintiffs said they hoped to expand the case beyond their clients into a class-action suit that could apply to all military members. 

The plaintiffs in the case are a Navy commander of a guided-missile destroyer who has 17 years of service and a Marine lieutenant colonel who serves as a diversity and inclusion officer and conducts research on integrating women into ground combat positions. They are represented by Liberty Counsel, a law firm that focuses on religious liberty cases, and both defendants filed for religious exemptions from the mandate based on their objections to vaccines created from aborted fetal stem cell lines.

The military, wrote Merryday, “is most likely unable to establish, and certainly has not established, that permitting the relatively small number of [requested religious exemptions] … will adversely affect the public’s interest in the maintenance and readiness of the nation’s military forces.

religious vaccine mandate
The decision on the Navy commander and the Marine lieutenant colonel’s case could have far-reaching consequences, as their lawyers hope to make the case a class-action suit on behalf of all those requesting religious exemptions from the COVID-19 vaccine mandate. US Navy photo by Paul Farley.

Merryday’s scathing decision references another lawsuit, filed in Texas, which also put a temporary halt on mandate-related discipline against 35 sailors, including multiple Navy SEALs, in January. But while each of these lawsuits has benefited only the plaintiffs in each specific case, a Liberty Counsel press release indicates the organization will ask Thursday for the injunction to be widened to other currently pending lawsuits. The firm will also seek to establish the case as a class-action suit that would include “all military service members, federal employees, and federal civilian contractor plaintiffs,” according to the press release.

Liberty Counsel founder and chairman Mat Staver said the judge had called out the Pentagon’s foot-dragging on religious exemptions.

“The military faces a trivial, if any, prospect of material injury as a result of permitting the service members continued service under the same terms and conditions and with the same privileges and emoluments as currently prevail, especially because the military permits a large group of unvaccinated persons to serve without adverse consequence,” Merryday wrote, referring to those with medical exemptions.

The Army began Wednesday to separate soldiers who refused the vaccine, following the lead of the Air Force, Marines, and Navy, which began discharging unvaccinated service members in the weeks following their vaccine mandate deadlines in late 2021.

Read Next: Marine Corps Grants Religious Exemptions for COVID-19 Vaccination

Maggie BenZvi
Maggie BenZvi

Maggie BenZvi is a contributing editor for Coffee or Die. She holds a bachelor’s degree in political science from the University of Chicago and a master’s degree in human rights from Columbia University, and has worked for the ACLU as well as the International Rescue Committee. She has also completed a summer journalism program at Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism. In addition to her work at Coffee or Die, she’s a stay-at-home mom and, notably, does not drink coffee. Got a tip? Get in touch!

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
9 Killed In Army Black Hawk Helicopter Crash In Kentucky

Nondice Thurman, a spokesperson for Fort Campbell, said Thursday morning that the deaths happened the previous night in southwestern Kentucky during a routine training mission.

March 30, 2023Associated Press
richard stayskal act military medical malpractice
DOD Denies Most Stayskal Act Malpractice Claims

Master Sgt. Richard Stayskal was diagnosed with lung cancer long after military doctors missed a tum...

March 29, 2023Maggie BenZvi
ukraine lessons learned
Opinion & Essay
Nolan Peterson: Lessons From Russia's Invasion of Ukraine

After living in and reporting from Ukraine the last nine years, conflict journalist Nolan Peterson h...

March 28, 2023Nolan Peterson
ukrainian wounded soldiers
‘On Tour In Hell’: Wounded Ukrainian Soldiers Evacuated

With bandaged heads and splinted limbs, the wounded soldiers are stretchered into the waiting medica...

March 27, 2023Associated Press
US oil mission
US Launches Airstrikes in Syria After Drone Kills US Worker

While it’s not the first time the U.S. and Iran have traded airstrikes in Syria, the attack and the ...

March 24, 2023Associated Press
The Gift jason dunham
‘The Gift’ Explores the Life and Legacy of Medal of Honor Recipient Jason Dunham

"The Gift" tells the story of the first Marine to receive the Medal of Honor after the Vietnam War. ...

March 24, 2023Mac Caltrider
uss milius
US Denies Chinese Claim It Drove Away American Destroyer

The U.S. Navy's 7th Fleet said that a statement from China's Southern Theatre Command that it had fo...

March 23, 2023Associated Press
The Speed Project: Vet Team To Run in Lawless, Invite-Only Ultramarathon

For the first time, a team of (mostly) US veterans and active-duty service members will run in The S...

March 23, 2023Jenna Biter
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved