Marine Commander Fired After Demanding Accountability for Afghanistan Failures

August 28, 2021Mac Caltrider

Marine Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller criticized senior leaders for their handling of the Afghan withdrawal. US Marine Corps photo.

A Marine commander has been fired after posting a widely shared video to Facebook in which he called out the Secretary of Defense, Commandant of the Marine Corps, and other senior military leadership and demanded accountability for the chaotic and deadly withdrawal from Afghanistan.

“Not making this video because it’s potentially an emotional time,” Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller says in the nearly five-minute video. “I’m making it because I have a growing discontent and contempt for my perceived ineptitude at the foreign policy level, and I want to specifically ask some questions to some of my senior leaders.”

Scheller, who has served as an infantry officer for 17 years, was the commanding officer of the Advanced Infantry Training Battalion at School of Infantry East. He completed one yearlong deployment to Afghanistan, according to his official biography.

“I want to say this very strongly,” Scheller says in the video. “I have been fighting for 17 years. I am willing to throw it all away to say to my senior leaders, I demand accountability.”

US Marine Brig. Gen. Farrell J. Sullivan, the commander of the Naval Amphibious Task Force 51, 5th Marine Expeditionary Brigade, speaks to Lt. Col. Brad Whited, commanding officer of 2nd Battalion, 1st Marine Regiment, during the evacuation at Hamid Karzai International Airport, Kabul, Afghanistan, Aug. 24, 2021. Photo courtesy of DVIDS.

Scheller confirmed his firing on his Facebook page.

“I have been relieved for cause based on a lack of trust and confidence as of 14:30 today,” he wrote. “My chain of command is doing exactly what I would do if I were in their shoes.”

In the video, Scheller asks senior leaders to hold themselves to the same standards of accountability as the rest of the military. In a letter dated Aug. 18, Commandant of the Marine Corps Gen. David Berger advised that Marines should seek community if they were struggling. Scheller acknowledged that he himself sought counseling, but he said that was not the solution for the current situation.

“There’s a time and place for that, but the reason people are so upset on social media right now is not because the Marine on the battlefield let someone down; that service member has always risen to the occasion and done extraordinary things,” he says in the video. “People are upset because their senior leaders let them down, and none of them are raising their hand and accepting accountability or saying ‘We messed this up.’”

Scheller says in the video that he understands the risk of calling out his leaders on social media, but he took the risk as a way of leading by example. 

“I think what you believe in can only be defined by what you are willing to risk,” Scheller says. “If I’m willing to risk my current battalion commander seat, my retirement, my family’s stability, to say some of the things I want to say, I think it gives me some moral high ground to demand the same honesty, integrity, and accountability from my senior leaders.

“If an O-5 Battalion Commander has the simplest live-fire incident or Equal Opportunity complaint, boom, fired. But we have a Secretary of Defense that testified to Congress in May that the Afghan National Security Force could withstand a Taliban advance,” he adds, in the wake of an avoidable loss of 13 lives.

The 19th sergeant major of the Marine Corps, Sgt. Maj. Troy E. Black, speaks to Marines attending the Basic Infantry Marine Course at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, Feb. 18, 2021. Department of Defense photo by Sgt. Victoria Ross.

Scheller then addresses the Marine Corps’ top leaders directly.

“Did any of you throw your rank on the table and say, ‘Hey, it’s a bad idea to evacuate Bagram Air Field, the strategic air base, before we evacuate everyone.Did anyone do that? And when you didn’t think to do that, did anyone raise their hand and say, ‘We completely messed this up’?” he asks angrily. 

Scheller points out that many veterans of the 20-year war are now wondering whether 2,461 of their comrades died in vain. 

“Potentially all those people did die in vain, if we don’t have senior leaders that own up and raise their hand and say, ‘We did not do this well in the end.’ Without that, we just keep repeating the same mistakes,” he answers.

Scheller’s terse remarks have been shared more than 14,600 times in less than 24 hours. He addressed the video to the American leadership and signed it “US.” As Americans are reeling from the devastating loss of 13 service members and dozens of Afghan civilians, Scheller seemed to capture what many are thinking.

A Marine assigned to the Special Purpose Marine Air Ground Task Force – Crisis Response – Central Command carries a child to be processed during the evacuation at Hamid Karzai International Airport, Kabul, Afghanistan, Aug. 25, 2021. Photo courtesy of the Department of Defense.

“This is obviously an emotional time for a lot of Marines, and we encourage anyone struggling right now to seek counseling or talk to a fellow Marine,” Marine spokesperson Maj. Jim Stenger said in an email to Coffee or Die Magazine. “There is a forum in which Marine leaders can address their disagreements with the chain of command, and it’s not social media.”

In the social media post announcing his firing, Scheller said that, while America “has many issues,” it’s “still the light shining in the fog of chaos.”

“When my Marine Corps career comes to an end, I look forward to a new beginning,” Scheller said. “My life’s purpose is to make America the most lethal and effective foreign diplomacy instrument. While my days of hand-to-hand violence may be ending … I see a new light on the horizon.”

Read Next: AFGHANISTAN UPDATE: Pentagon Confirms 13 US Service Members Killed in Suicide Bombing Outside Kabul Airport

Mac Caltrider
Mac Caltrider

Mac Caltrider is a senior staff writer for Coffee or Die Magazine. He served in the US Marine Corps and is a former police officer. Caltrider earned his bachelor’s degree in history and now reads anything he can get his hands on. He is also the creator of Pipes & Pages, a site intended to increase readership among enlisted troops. Caltrider spends most of his time reading, writing, and waging a one-man war against premature hair loss.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
Robert Heinlein: The Navy Vet Who Pioneered Sci-Fi

The dean of science fiction combined his experiences in the Navy with his knowledge as an aeronautical engineer to create genre-transforming novels.

January 27, 2023Mac Caltrider
Masih Alinejad
Feds: Brooklyn Cops Foil Brazen Iranian Plot to Murder Masih Alinejad

Three men reputedly linked to Eastern European mobsters and Iranian intelligence operatives have been arrested.

January 27, 2023Carl Prine
FILE - Ukrainian soldiers on captured Russian tanks T-72 hold military training close to the Ukraine-Belarus border near Chernihiv, Ukraine, Friday, Oct. 28, 2022. The West's move to send tanks to Ukraine was greeted enthusiastically from Kyiv, Berlin and Washington. But Moscow seemed to shrug. The Kremlin has warned the West that supplying tanks would be a dangerous escalation of the conflict and denounced the decision. AP photo by Aleksandr Shulman, File.
Russia Responds to Ukraine’s ‘Tanksgiving’ With Missile and Drone Strikes

Hours after the US and Germany agreed to send battle tanks to Ukraine, Russia launched missile and drone strikes at targets across the country.

January 26, 2023Nolan Peterson
Marine Corps Dedicates First New Base in 7 Decades

For the first time in seven decades, the US Marine Corps is building a new base.

January 26, 2023Carl Prine
US Sending Nearly a Battalion of Abrams Tanks to Ukraine

The US will send 31 Abrams tanks to Ukraine after months of uncertainty.

January 26, 2023Associated Press
The damaged tug Mark E. Kuebler grounded near Corpus Christi, Texas, on Sunday, Jan. 22, 2023. A large gash is visible just above the waterline. Photos courtesy of Boatswain’s Mate 2nd Class Merrit Carter. Composite by Kenna Lee/Coffee or Die Magazine.
Coast Guard Coxswain Emphasizes Having Clear Head During Tugboat Response

One of the world’s most innovative tugboats remains beached on a Texas sandbar, after apparently getting sucked under a massive oil tanker and mauled by its propeller.

January 26, 2023Noelle Wiehe
Coffee Or Die Photo
The ‘Tallinn Pledge’ for Ukraine: NATO V2.0?

Representatives from nine NATO countries gathered in Estonia and pledged more military aid for Ukraine.

January 20, 2023Nolan Peterson
Coffee Or Die Photo
Triple Seven Expedition
DISPATCH: With Celebratory Jump in Florida, Triple 7 Expedition Is a Wrap

The Triple 7 Expedition's team of nine vets wrapped up its breakneck skydiving expedition with a final, celebratory jump in Florida on Wednesday, Jan. 18.

January 20, 2023Jenna Biter
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved