Military Ordered To Overhaul How It Prevents, Tracks Civilian Deaths

January 28, 2022Hannah Ray Lambert
civilian deaths

The Department of Defense must develop a plan to track and reduce civilian deaths during military operations, according to a directive issued Thursday by Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin. Ten civilians were killed Aug. 29, 2021, in Kabul in a botched drone strike. Photos courtesy of Getty and Department of Defense. Composite by Coffee or Die Magazine.

Word emerged Thursday, Jan. 27, that the Pentagon will overhaul how it tracks and avoids civilian deaths in combat, just as a major study announced US war planners are “not adequately organized, structured, or resourced” to tackle the problem of US forces harming noncombatants.

The move comes on the heels of intense scrutiny and public backlash over high-profile airstrikes, such as the botched drone strike that killed 10 Afghan civilians, most of them children, on Aug. 29, 2021, in Kabul.

Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin on Thursday instructed the Department of Defense to develop a plan to track and reduce civilian deaths during military operations.

“The protection of civilians is fundamentally consistent with the effective, efficient, and decisive use of force in pursuit of U.S. national interests, and our efforts to mitigate and respond to civilian harm are a direct reflection of U.S. values,” Austin wrote in a two-page memo to top civilian and military leaders. “It is a strategic and a moral imperative.”

civilian deaths drone strikes
MQ-9 Reaper aircrew from the 22nd Attack Squadron fly a training mission at Creech Air Force Base, Nevada, April 15, 2020. US Air Force photo by Airman 1st Class William Rio Rosado.

The new directive came the same day the Rand Corp. released its congressionally mandated report on the US military’s civilian casualty policies and procedures. The nonpartisan think tank determined the military did not use lessons learned from past mistakes during 20 years of war that could have reduced civilian casualties.

“Even the individuals involved in an incident often never saw the results of the investigation, so they could not learn lessons from what happened,” researchers wrote.

Both the DOD’s internal and external reporting on civilian casualties is often unreliable or incomplete, according to the report. Senior researcher Michael McNerney put it more bluntly, according to The Hill, calling the Pentagon’s data management “a hot mess” with information scattered on various drives and no central system allowing for analysis.

Austin expects the DOD to tackle that problem. In Thursday’s memo, he asked for the creation of a Civilian Harm Mitigation and Response Action Plan (CHMRAP) within 90 days. As part of the CHMRAP, Austin expects the DOD to develop better civilian-harm operational reporting and data management processes.

“The end of our military mission in Afghanistan and our transition in Iraq to an advisory capacity … offer us new opportunities to improve our ability to mitigate and respond to civilian harm,” Austin wrote in his memo.

Kabul drone strike review civilian deaths
The drone strike that killed 43-year-old Zemari Ahmadi and nine members of his family Aug. 29, 2021, was a mistake, but not a criminal one, according to a review by the Air Force inspector general. Photos courtesy of DOD, Nutrition and Education International. Composite by Coffee or Die Magazine.

The Kabul drone strike that came at the close of the US withdrawal from Afghanistan highlights the risk to civilians. After a suicide bombing killed 13 US troops, the military believed another attack was imminent and mistakenly killed an aid worker and his family. Following the strike, American officials initially insisted the target had been another ISIS-K suicide bomber, with Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark A. Milley going so far as to refer to the strike as “righteous.” But after media investigations, top US officials reversed course in September and admitted the targeting decisions behind the strike had been flawed.

Pentagon estimates of civilians killed in US military operations have often been far lower than reliable outside estimates, the Rand report found. For example, the DOD reported just 21 civilian deaths in Syria in 2019, but third-party estimates ranged from 490 to 1,118 deaths. Likewise in Afghanistan, the DOD reported 108 civilian deaths in 2019 while outside groups reported 559 deaths.

Rand researchers also found the DOD’s responses to civilian casualties “have historically been inconsistent and confusing” and recommended the DOD be more transparent and avoid “overly restrictive limits” on where, why, and to whom the military distributes condolence payments.

Payments in the wake of noncombatant casualties, sometimes referred to as ex gratia payments, were another area where Austin’s memo appears to concur with the Rand report. Austin directed the DOD to review how it responds to civilian casualties — including condolence payouts and public acknowledgement — and incorporate guidance for addressing civilian harm into doctrine and operational plans.

Read Next: Pentagon Names 10 Bases for Potential Deployment for Ukraine

Hannah Ray Lambert
Hannah Ray Lambert

Hannah Ray Lambert is a former staff writer for Coffee or Die who previously covered everything from murder trials to high school trap shooting teams. She spent several months getting tear gassed during the 2020-2021 civil unrest in Portland, Oregon. When she’s not working, Hannah enjoys hiking, reading, and talking about authors and books on her podcast Between Lewis and Lovecraft.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
How the Bazooka Gained Infamy as a Tank-Buster

Named after a musical instrument, the Bazooka proved to be a highly effective weapon for American troops, including one maverick pilot, throughout multiple wars.

Secretary of the Air Force Frank Kendall (center) delivers testimony during a House Appropriations Committee hearing in the Capitol Building, Washington, D.C.
Home to Glenn, Armstrong, Wrights Perfect Spot for Space Command HQ, Ohio Lawmakers Say

Ohio lawmakers pitch their state as the new location for Space Command headquarters.

Soflete: How This Veteran-Led Company is Changing Military Fitness Culture

In 2014, Soflete’s co-founders saw workout overkill hurting their peers as they prepared for selecti...

glock 19
Glock 19: Origin Story of a Legendary Pistol

Get to know the Glock 19 — how it works, who uses it, and why it’s one of the most popular handguns in the US.

afghan soldier asylum
Afghan Soldier Who Helped US Weathers Injuries, Uncertainty in Asylum Bid

Afghan soldier who assisted the U.S. now faces uncertainty in bid for asylum.

The Dirty Dozen
‘The Dirty Dozen’: Meet D-Day’s Real Rogue Commandos

The Dirty Dozen was based on a real team of rule-breaking elite paratroopers who jumped into France ahead of D-Day.

d-day 79th anniversary
Normandy Marks D-Day's 79th Anniversary, Honors World War II Veterans

This year's D-Day tribute to the young soldiers who died in Normandy is not only a chance to honor t...

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved