Republican Lawmakers Question Pentagon Vaccine Mandate, but Full Approval Expected Soon

August 11, 2021Dustin Jones
Republican lawmakers do not believe a Pentagon-wide vaccine mandate is legal under current “emergency” approvals, but full approval for most COVID-19 vaccinations is expected soon. US Army National Guard photo by Sgt. Leona C. Hendrickson.

Republican lawmakers do not believe a Pentagon-wide vaccine mandate is legal under current “emergency” approvals, but full approval for most COVID-19 vaccinations is expected soon. US Army National Guard photo by Sgt. Leona C. Hendrickson.

Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin announced Monday that he intends to mandate all US military troops, civilian contractors, and employees to be vaccinated for COVID-19 by mid-September. But some military members — and several Republican lawmakers — say he can’t do that, at least not yet. The real answer appears to be: Well … it depends.

On Friday, Aug. 6, Rep. Mark Green of Tennessee and 15 other members of Congress wrote Lloyd a memo insisting that a mandate for any of the commercially available COVID-19 vaccines, which are all currently being used under an emergency use authorization from the Federal Drug Administration, would be illegal. 

“The law of the United States is clear: Mandatory vaccination is illegal for military personnel prior to complete approval,” the memo reads. “As long as the vaccine is authorized under an Emergency Use Authorization, the Department of Defense does not have the authority to implement such an order.

“The Secretary of Defense is not above the law.”

In a letter to Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, 16 Republican lawmakers asserted that a COVID-19 vaccine mandate would be illegal.

The letter cites a case, Doe v. Rumsfeld, in which a federal district court sided with service members against involuntary anthrax vaccinations in 2003. The court said the Pentagon could not require military personnel or civilian contract employees to receive experimental drugs without a waiver signed by the president.

For the time being, all three COVID-19 vaccines circulating in the United States have received approval only for emergency use. An emergency use authorization, or EUA, is used for vaccines in the case of public health crises and require less — though still rigorous — safety testing than final approval, which may be granted after a drug undergoes what is known as a BLA, or biologics license application. Once a medicine or vaccine receives a biologics license, it is considered fully approved for all clinical uses intended.

In terms of the current COVID-19 vaccines, the two approvals vary in small but important ways:

  • Both approvals require three phases of human testing, but an EUA can be issued with two months of safety data following phase 3 study participants’ completion of the vaccine regimen. A BLA requires at least six months of safety data following phase 3 study participants’ completion of the vaccine regimen.

  • A manufacturer’s creation process and manufacturing facilities must all pass a full FDA inspection to receive BLA approval.

  • An EUA product must be shown to be safe in clinical trials and that it “is reasonable to believe that the product may be effective.” The bar is higher for a BLA, in which a product must demonstrate through trials that it is clearly a potent remedy in its intended use (the COVID-19 vaccines available in the US all are considered extremely effective, even under an EUA).

Additionally, an EUA approval is automatically nullified if an emergency ends, whereas a biologics license, once issued, is indefinite. A drug with an EUA can only be used as specifically authorized. In contrast, doctors and patients can agree to “off-label” use of drugs that have a biologics license — with the COVID-19 vaccines, for instance, parents and doctors could decide to vaccinate children under 12, if the vaccines receive their biologics license.

Washington state vaccine lottery veterans eligibility
An airman assigned to the 48th Fighter Wing Medical Group receives the COVID-19 vaccine at Royal Air Force Lakenheath, England, Dec. 29, 2020. US Air Force photo by Senior Airman Madeline Herzog.

However, the rules cited in the congressional letter could be subject to a presidential override, and full approval of the vaccines may come within weeks. And even if COVID-19 vaccines can’t be legally mandatory, that doesn’t mean refusing the vaccine would be without consequences.

A law professor with experience as both an Air Force officer and a military trial judge said that refusal to get vaccinated could leave military members without jobs.

University of New Mexico law professor Joshua Kastenberg spent 20 years as a lawyer and trial judge in the Air Force. Any case of vaccine refusal would likely turn on the military’s need for its members to travel the world, he said. And when a member’s capability to deploy is impaired or compromised, the military has little use for that person.

“The ability to serve in the military is predicated to mainly serve in a worldwide capability. They can send you to Germany, Iraq — anywhere in the world — tomorrow,” Kastenberg said. “But if you’re not capable of worldwide deployment you can be discharged from the military at any time. It’s an all or nothing thing.”

A law professor and 20-year military judge believes that military members refusing a vaccine mandate, especially after full approval by the FDA, could be out of a job. US Air Force photo by Airman 1st Class William Rosado.

DOD personnel who refuse to get the vaccine and can no longer perform their necessary duties, including deployment, could face administrative separation. And that consequence has already met constitutional approval.

The individual could fight the vaccine requirement, Kastenberg said, but judges have traditionally sided with the government and military necessity on similar cases. 

One thing is clear: If President Joe Biden signs a waiver for the mandate — or if the FDA grants the vaccines full biologics licensure — refusal to get the shot will be (outside of established issues) essentially indefensible.

“There will be an order that is presumed to be lawful, and to defy that would be at your own risk,” Kastenberg warned. Refusing a lawful order violates Article 92 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice. It typically results in a court-martial and carries a maximum penalty of a dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, as well as confinement for up to two years.

Read Next: ‘V-Day’: Sept. 15 Deadline Set for Military Vaccine Mandate

Dustin Jones
Dustin Jones

Dustin Jones is a former senior staff writer for Coffee or Die Magazine covering military and intelligence news. Jones served four years in the Marine Corps with tours to Iraq and Afghanistan. He studied journalism at the University of Colorado and Columbia University. He has worked as a reporter in Southwest Montana and at NPR. A New Hampshire native, Dustin currently resides in Southern California.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
navy seal training
Navy SEALS Training Plagued by Massive Problems, According To Investigation

Medical oversight and care were “poorly organized, poorly integrated and poorly led and put candidat...

memorial day arlington
Memorial Day Is a Day of Remembrance, Not Celebration

Memorial Day was created as a remembrance to honor the fallen by decorating graves — a holiday meant...

air force joint chiefs
Air Force Fighter Pilot Tapped As Next Joint Chiefs Chairman Has History of Firsts

The Air Force fighter pilot about to be nominated as the next chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff ...

sowf special operations warrior foundation
BRCC Donates $500K to Special Operations Warrior Foundation

In an effort to continue Black Rifle Coffee Company’s mission of supporting the veteran community, B...

Coca Cola 600
BRCC to Honor Fallen Marine During NASCAR’s Legendary Coca-Cola 600

Black Rifle Coffee Company will honor Marine Gunnery Sgt. Joseph Menusa during NASCAR’s Coca-Cola 600 this Memorial Day. Menusa was killed in 2003 during the invasion of Iraq.

uss gerald r. ford oslo
US Aircraft Carrier Arrives In NATO Member Norway, To Take Part In Drills

The nuclear-powered ship USS Gerald R. Ford entered the Oslo fjord escorted by a rapid dinghy-type boat with armed personnel on board.

adam driver indy 500
Marine Vet, Actor Adam Driver Named Honorary Starter for Indianapolis 500

Two-time Academy Award nominee Adam Driver, who will soon be starring as Enzo Ferrari in a biopic of...

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved