Questions Mount After Army Charges 82nd Airborne Paratrooper for Syrian Firefight

May 13, 2021James R. Webb
Nicoson Syria

SFC Nicoson in Syria.

There wasn’t a cloud in the sky outside of Tal al-Zahab, Syria, on the morning of Aug. 17, 2020. That day, Army Sgt. 1st Class Robert Nicoson, his platoon commander, and 16 soldiers of his patrol from the 82nd Airborne Division drove down a thin ribbon of blacktop toward a pro-Syrian regime checkpoint outside of town.

It was a routine anti-ISIS security patrol in the sweltering August heat of the Syrian desert, until it wasn’t.

Minutes after being cleared to pass through the checkpoint, Nicoson and his soldiers were attacked by the same fighters granting them passage. Within weeks of the firefight, Nicoson’s bravery under fire led to a recommendation for a Bronze Star with a “V” for valor. Months later, Nicoson now finds himself facing charges that effectively pin the blame for the firefight on him, even though Nicoson’s platoon commander was present on the patrol, and the Department of Defense stated the soldiers had acted in self-defense.

“I can’t see why the sergeant is being handled more roughly than the platoon leader […] none of this happens if the platoon leader doesn’t put them there,” retired Marine Corps Lt. Col. Robert Bracknell, a former military lawyer, told Coffee or Die Magazine in an interview. Bracknell has advanced training in international and operational law, along with a master’s of laws from Harvard University.

The Operation Inherent Resolve press release regarding the incident read, “After receiving safe passage from the pro-regime forces, the patrol came under small arms fire from individuals at the checkpoint. Coalition troops returned fire in self-defense.”

According to the Army Times, the roughly 10-minute firefight left one Syrian fighter dead and two more wounded. Nicoson is credited with exiting his vehicle in order to deliberately draw the fire of attacking Syrians so that his men could reload. However, a yet-to-be-released Army Criminal Investigative Division report effectively blamed Nicoson for the incident.

Later this month, Nicoson faces a hearing on multiple charges stemming from the firefight in Syria, including two counts of failure to follow a lawful order, two counts of reckless endangerment, one count of wrongful communication, and three counts of obstruction of justice.

“The gravamen of the issue is the unit placed itself in a position it shouldn’t have been in, and apparently the sergeant made it worse by being mouthy and provocative,” Bracknell told Coffee or Die.

The chain of events leading to the firefight remain murky. Additionally, Army officials are holding Nicoson, rather than the platoon commander who was present at the time of the incident, accountable for the soldiers being too close to Syrian positions during the patrol.

Syria firefight charges for Sgt. Robert Nicoson
Soldiers with 1st Battalion, 6th Infantry Regiment, 2nd Armored Brigade Combat Team, 1st Armored Division, stand guard in the Central Command area of responsibility, Jan. 18, 2021. US Army photo by Spc. Jensen Guillory, courtesy of DVIDS.

“But what they are alleging is that [Nicoson] sort of prospectively threatened the forces at the checkpoint — that if they shot or attacked [the Americans] … harm would come to them,” Nicoson’s civilian defense attorney, Phillip Stackhouse, told the Army Times. “Being there to begin with, they’re saying, is reckless endangerment.”

Stackhouse told the Army Times that soldiers in Nicoson’s unit were told to stay a minimum of 2 kilometers (1.24 miles) away from a particular Syrian force position. However, missions in which Nicoson was involved brought them within that 2-kilometer boundary. Stackhouse suggests that this was not the first time that Nicoson and his soldiers were in close proximity to pro-Syrian regime forces.

But combat operations throughout the Middle East are often murky, with combatant forces that ebb and flow across a battlespace rife with competing factions and a mix of regular and irregular forces. Along that line of thinking, a fixed 2-kilometer boundary may not have been a realistic expectation, Bracknell said.

“The Syrian forces may have been mobile, as well, and likely got a vote in how close they got to American forces,” Bracknell said. “What I don’t really understand is if Nicoson was within 2 kilometers, wasn’t the platoon leader within 2 kilometers as well? Who is responsible for that proximity?” 

Syria Army Nicoson
An M2 Bradley Infantry Fighting Vehicle, with Alpha Troop, 1st Battalion, 6th Infantry Regiment, 2nd Armored Brigade Combat Team, 1st Armored Division, pulls security during a convoy in northeast Syria, Oct. 21, 2020. US Army photo by Spc. Jensen Guillory, courtesy of DVIDS.

Stackhouse told the Army Times that the platoon commander was in one of the “lead” vehicles of the convoy, while Nicoson was in the last vehicle of the movement. As the encounter devolved into violence, the platoon commander was on the radio with higher headquarters and Nicoson was communicating to the pro-regime forces through an interpreter, where he issued his alleged threat of violence should his soldiers come under attack.

These types of threats are not uncommon in warfare, and ultimately it is the duty of officers and senior noncommissioned officers to ensure the safety of those in their command.

Marine Gen. James Mattis famously told tribal leaders in Iraq’s Anbar province: “I come in peace. I didn’t bring artillery. But I’m pleading with you, with tears in my eyes — if you fuck with me, I’ll kill you all.”

Mattis’ statement is celebrated for its bravado. However, it was ultimately intended to prevent unnecessary violence.

“The hair trigger for a platoon at a checkpoint with irregular forces is a lot more touchy than Mattis’ bravado,” Bracknell said. “It’s not apples and oranges, but it’s Red Delicious and Granny Smith.”

syria army nicoson
On Dec. 8, 2006, then Lt. Gen. James M. Mattis, commanding general, US Marine Forces Central Command and 1st Marine Expeditionary Force, speaks with Marines during a visit at Camp Taqaddum, Iraq. US Marine Corps photo by Lance Cpl. Ryan L. Tomlinson, courtesy of DVIDS.

Twitter video of the firefight shows Nicoson’s unit engaged and clearly with the upper hand. A cacophony of American small-arms and machine-gun fire rains down on pro-Syrian regime positions; it’s unclear whether the Americans are engaging uniformed Syrians.

“If the irregulars were in plain clothes, the government’s evidence would have to show facts that put the accused on notice they were irregular fighters — armament, location, types of vehicles driven, et cetera. If the evidence showed the irregulars really blended into the population, this might be hard for the government to prove,” Bracknell said.

Another aspect of the case is the appearance of an Apache helicopter. Video posted to Twitter of the engagement shows an Apache orbiting above the checkpoint. The Army Times reports that the attack helicopter conducted a show of force prior to the gunfight, a move that is typically requested by an officer, and an indication that troops on the ground are under fire.

syria nicoson army
An AH-64 Apache Attack Helicopter hovers before takeoff. A 30 mm automatic Boeing M230 chain gun is located under the fuselage. It provides a rate of fire of 625 rounds per minute. The helicopter has capacity for up to 1,200 rounds of ammunition. US Army photo by Master Sgt. John Nimmo Sr., courtesy of DVIDS.

“Almost certainly the Apache was responding to the platoon leader’s request for support, though it could have been vectored there by a [Combat Operations Center] based on their independent assessment, imagery, blue force tracker type info,” Bracknell told Coffee or Die. “But probably [it was] requested by the platoon leader. It’s just hard to say why.”

Following Nicoson’s hearing on charges at the end of May, more details should emerge surrounding the incident. Clearly, Nicoson acted with courage during the firefight. His individual actions, which the Army initially lauded, almost certainly ensured that none of his soldiers were killed or wounded.

“I’m not sure how you hold the platoon sergeant accountable,” Bracknell said.

Read Next: Bombings Kill Dozens of Afghan Civilians, With Schoolgirls Among the Targets

James R. Webb
James R. Webb

James Webb served as a US Marine infantryman from 2005 to 2010, completing a combat tour in Iraq. He’s worked as a freelance writer and photojournalist covering US troops in Afghanistan, and Webb spent more than two years in the US Senate as a military legislative assistant and as the personal representative of a member on the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
‘Butter Butter Jam!’: Troops Loved, and Hated, the M249 SAW

For nearly 50 years, the SAW has played a major role in America’s wars. Now it’s being replaced by new weapons.

February 8, 2023Mac Caltrider
Coffee Or Die Photo
Space Force Vows ‘Above and Beyond’ Cleanup of Maui Spill

Brig. Gen. Anthony Mastalir, the commander of the U.S. Space Forces Indo-Pacific, said a team will t...

February 8, 2023Associated Press
Coffee Or Die Photo
Navy Releases First Photos of Chinese Balloon Recovery

In the newest images released by the Navy on Tuesday, sailors from Explosive Ordnance Disposal Group...

February 7, 2023Associated Press
Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin speaks at the Pentagon in Washington, Nov. 16, 2022. Lawyers for a group of Navy SEALS and other Navy personnel who oppose a COVID-19 vaccination requirement on religious grounds want a federal appeals court to keep alive their legal fight against the Biden administration. Congress voted to end the requirement in December 2022, but vaccine opponents note that commanders can still make decisions on how and whether to deploy unvaccinated troops, under a memo signed last month by Austin. AP photo by Susan Walsh, File.
Vaccine Litigation Lingers After Lifting of Military Mandate

Lawyers for a group of Navy SEALS and other Navy personnel who refuse to be vaccinated for religious...

February 7, 2023Associated Press
Armed Forces Service Medal
Who Earns the Armed Forces Service Medal?

The Department of Defense honors heroism in combat in many ways, but there is also an award — the Ar...

February 7, 2023Noelle Wiehe
Soldiers carry the coffin of Eduard Strauss, a Ukrainian serviceman who died in combat on Jan. 17 in Bakhmut, during a farewell ceremony in Kyiv, Ukraine, Monday, Feb. 6, 2023. AP photo by Daniel Cole.
Russian Forces Keep Up Pressue As Ukraine Anniversary Nears

Russian forces are keeping Ukrainian troops tied down with attacks in the eastern Donbas region as M...

February 7, 2023Associated Press
Chinese spy balloon
Blown to Bits! Chinese Spy Balloon Blasted, Plummets Into Sea

The US Air Force downed the Chinese balloon that's been soaring over the US.

February 4, 2023Carl Prine
germany, european union, ukraine gas reserves
Ukraine Wants To Store Europe’s Strategic Gas Reserves

Ukraine maintains 12 underground gas storage facilities with a total capacity of about 31 billion cu...

February 3, 2023Nolan Peterson
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved