He’s a Pretty Good Petty Officer, so Why’s Big Navy Kicking Him Out?

December 27, 2021Carl Prine
Petty Officer Jonathan Bartlett

Logistics Specialist 2nd Class Jonathan Bartlett services a hydraulic system on a Blue Angels F/A-18 Hornet strike fighter, during morning turns March 9, 2018, at California’s Naval Air Facility El Centro. US Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Ian Cotter.

Logistics Specialist 2nd Class Jonathan Bartlett has been in the Navy for seven years, and he thought he was a pretty good petty officer. He served with the sea service’s daredevil aerial acrobats, the Blue Angels, and now he’s supporting explosive ordnance disposal teams in Virginia.

So he’s a little puzzled about why the Navy’s top personnel officer, Vice Adm. John B. Nowell Jr., wants to boot him and most of the other 5,360 sailors who haven’t received the COVID-19 vaccine.

“We’re patriots,” Bartlett, 26, told Coffee or Die Magazine. “We’re standing up for our rights.”

And a key right enshrined in the Constitution, statute, and Navy regulations and traditions, is that every sailor is afforded due process of law. But the Navy wants personnel to waive that right to garner coveted honorable discharges.

COVID-19 vaccine navy
Chief Navy Counselor Agnieszka Grzelczyk, from Navy Talent Acquisition Group Philadelphia, receives the COVID-19 vaccine at New Jersey’s Naval Weapons Station Earle, March 10, 2021. US Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Diana Quinlan.

Bartlett and other sailors point to the Navy’s contradictory regulations on this subject. They say the Navy’s new mandate for disposing of COVID-19 refuseniks — NAVADMIN 283/21 — conflicts with MILPERSMAN 1910-302.

NAVADMIN 283/21 states sailors like Bartlett with more than six years of service will be booted from the service with a general under honorable conditions discharge, unless they agree to waive their due process rights to review by administrative separation boards or boards of inquiry.

Then they’ll get honorable discharges, barring “additional misconduct or unique circumstances.”

But MILPERSMAN 1910-302 tells commanders that a sailor’s discharge generally “will be based upon the member’s total performance of duty and conduct during the current enlistment,” unless there’s a “single incident” that’s so terrible it downgrades the characterization.

The regulation doesn’t specify whether declining the COVID-19 vaccine on medical or religious grounds would trigger an adverse discharge.

COVID-19 booster
Hospital Corpsman 2nd Class Jose Torres administers the COVID-19 booster vaccination to Sgt. Timothy Evans, 11th Marine Expeditionary Unit, on board the amphibious assault ship Essex on Dec. 20, 2021, in the Gulf of Aden. US Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Isaak Martinez.

This apparent contradiction in the regs has left sailors to ask whether they’re in the bizarro world of Navy personnel policies. A sailor who has served honorably will be administratively discharged with a general characterization; a peer who hasn’t served with honor will get an honorable discharge merely by waiving due process rights.

And what will sailors do if they take the honorable discharge deal and the Navy tacks the dreaded RE-4 reenlistment code to it? That subtle black mark tells future recruiters and potential employers that despite the honorable discharge, the sailor isn’t welcome back in the military, even with a waiver.

Bartlett, the logistics specialist, moonlights as a real estate agent and was considering joining a Navy Reserve unit when he exits active-duty service. RE-4 will block that.

“That’s b.s.,” Bartlett said. “I’ve given nothing but honorable service and I’d like to keep serving.”

petty officer COVID-19
Vice Adm. John Nowell, chief of naval personnel, asks questions about a menu during Food Truck Fest, held Sept. 8, 2021, at Naval Support Facility Arlington in Virginia. US Navy photo by Elizabeth Kearns.

Bartlett’s pro bono attorney in Texas, Brian Ferguson, tried to get clarification on the Navy’s HR policies by shooting the chief of naval personnel an email. To Ferguson, the Navy’s NAVADMIN 283/21 appears “arbitrary” and “capricious.”

And under federal statute, that could make NAVADMIN 283/21 unlawful and unenforceable.

Nowell never responded to Ferguson. And when Coffee or Die tried to follow up with Nowell’s command about these issues, no one responded to the magazine’s messages.

On Dec. 22, however, Nowell’s legal counsel got back to Ferguson.

“I understand the objection you raise below, and you remain free to levy this argument in any and all future forums from which you seek redress, to include administrative hearing boards, boards of inquiry, the Board for Correction of Naval Records or other civil/administrative bodies,” Capt. Phillip A. Chockley wrote. “However, at this time, you should anticipate no additional action or response from the Chief of Naval Personnel.”

petty officer COVID-19
Chief of Naval Personnel Vice Adm. John Nowell discusses COVID-19 concerns with sailors and civilians assigned to Navy Talent Acquisition Group New England in Boston on June 23, 2021. US Navy photo by Chief Mass Communication Specialist Joshua Wahl.

Ferguson told Coffee or Die he’s representing 20 other clients facing involuntary separation because they don’t want to get the COVID-19 vaccine. He suspects “a lot of people” will end up taking the honorable discharge, even if it comes with what he calls the “Scarlet Letter of the RE-4.”

So why even offer the honorable discharge? Why doesn’t the Navy just give everyone a general under honorable conditions discharge and let them duke it out with a board over the characterization?

Every sailor has the right to be represented at an administrative discharge board by detailed military counsel.

“The real reason you’re seeing this is because the Navy doesn’t have enough defense attorneys to get these sailors out on time,” Ferguson said. “Too many resisted. The only way to get them out is to induce them to give up on a board.”

Hospital Corpsman 2nd Class Tessa Hazard
Hospital Corpsman 2nd Class Tessa Hazard, a respiratory therapist specialist, returned to Washington’s Navy Medicine Readiness and Training Command Bremerton after deploying on behalf of Joint Task Force Civil Support for approximately eight weeks to Ozark, Alabama, Dec. 1, 2021. US Navy photo by Douglas H Stutz.

Bartlett is in a legal limbo. He’s been given no date for when he’ll be administratively separated from the service or a time and place to go before a board to contest it.

He’s already recovered once from COVID-19 and “didn’t lose the sense of smell or anything like that.” He told Coffee or Die he’s a healthy man, packed now with natural immunity from the disease, and he believes he can make an adult decision about his medical need for the vaccine.

Bartlett’s commanding officer and command master chief have talked to him about it, and he respects their perspectives. And if the Food and Drug Administration okayed a vaccine better than the immunity he has now, he’d consider taking it. He admits he’s had a few doubts about his stand, but for now he’s resolved to fight it out.

“I question it all the time,” he said.

COVID-19 child vaccine
Hospitalman Lucas Lee, from Naples, Florida, assigned to the aircraft carrier Ronald Reagan, administers a COVID-19 vaccine to a child at The Sullivans Elementary School on Commander Fleet Activities Yokosuka in Japan on Nov. 19, 2021. US Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Reina J. Delgado.

As of Dec. 22, 5,361 active-duty sailors remain unvaccinated. The Navy has granted seven permanent medical exemptions, 140 temporary medical exemptions, and 158 administrative exemptions, according to the Pentagon.

The Navy says 2,844 active-duty sailors have requested a religious waiver from COVID-19 immunization, and the service approved zero of them.

On Dec. 18, Lt. Ivey Quintana-Martinez from the Navy Reserve Center San Diego, became the 17th sailor to die from COVID-19.

The Navy estimates 51,230 sailors have contracted the disease and recovered from it.

Read Next: Navy Officer Sues His Bosses Over Pentagon’s COVID-19 Vaccination Mandate 

Carl Prine
Carl Prine

Carl Prine is a former senior editor at Coffee or Die Magazine. He has worked at Navy Times, The San Diego Union-Tribune, and Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. He served in the Marine Corps and the Pennsylvania Army National Guard. His awards include the Joseph Galloway Award for Distinguished Reporting on the military, a first prize from Investigative Reporters & Editors, and the Combat Infantryman Badge.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
US: War Crimes on All Sides in Ethiopia's Tigray Conflict

The Biden administration announced Monday that it has determined all sides in the brutal conflict in Ethiopia’s northern Tigray region committed war crimes and crimes against humanity.

March 20, 2023Associated Press
military pilots cancer rates
Higher Cancer Rates Found in Military Pilots, Ground Crews

In its yearlong study of almost 900,000 service members who flew on or worked on military aircraft b...

March 20, 2023Associated Press
whiskey pour
Veterans Lead the Way Among America’s Growing Craft Distilleries

American veterans are taking the lessons they learned in the military and changing the craft distilling industry.

March 20, 2023Mac Caltrider
military suicide veteran suicide
Military Moves To Cut Suicides, But Defers Action on Guns

In a memo released Thursday, Austin called for the establishment of a suicide prevention working gro...

March 17, 2023Associated Press
us military drills japan-south korea
US, Partners Stage Military Drills Amid Japan-South Korea Talks

The Sea Dragon 23 exercises that started on Wednesday will culminate in more than 270 hours of in-fl...

March 17, 2023Associated Press
leo jenkins a word like god
‘A Word Like God’: New Book From Army Ranger Leo Jenkins

In his latest poetry collection, Ranger-turned-writer Leo Jenkins turns away from war to explore cosmic themes of faith, fatherhood, and art.

March 16, 2023Mac Caltrider
us drone
Pentagon Video Shows Russian Jet Dumping Fuel on US Drone

The Pentagon on Thursday released video of what it said was a Russian fighter jet dumping fuel on a ...

March 16, 2023Associated Press
10th Mountain Division
‘Climb to Glory’ — A History of the US Army’s 10th Mountain Division

From the mountains of Italy to the mountains of Afghanistan, the US Army’s 10th Mountain Division built its legendary reputation by fighting in some of the most inhospitable places in the world.

March 16, 2023Matt Fratus
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved