Judge Delivers Verdict Amid Questions About Brass Misconduct in Scheller Case

October 15, 2021Carl Prine
Verdict brass Scheller

Marine Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller hands a copy of his unsworn testimony to reporters Friday, Oct. 15, 2021, the second day of his special court-martial trial at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina. Scheller, right, spent 17 years in the Marine Corps and was decorated for battlefield valor in Afghanistan. Photo at left by Noelle Wiehe/Coffee or Die Magazine. Photo at right courtesy of Pipe Hitters Foundation.

CAMP LEJEUNE, N.C. — Seeing a man in pain, confused, and frustrated by events on an Afghanistan battlefield far from here, Marine Reserve judge Col. Glen R. Hines delivered his verdict and sentenced outspoken Stuart Scheller, a Marine lieutenant colonel, to a $5,000 fine and a letter of reprimand for his social media campaign against the Pentagon brass.

Hines’ Friday, Oct. 15, verdict capped a brief two-day special court-martial trial here, only 50 days after Scheller posted a video demanding senior leader accountability for a bungled withdrawal of US forces from Afghanistan.

Scheller told the judge during his guilty plea hearing Wednesday that his online crusade cost him his wife, career, military mentors, a side business, and the friendship of many Marine buddies.

Scheller didn’t speak to reporters after departing the courthouse here. Flanked by his parents, he trudged into the North Carolina sunshine to begin the last several months of his 17-year Marine Corps career, awaiting only a decision from the secretary of the Navy on his discharge.

In a plea agreement leaked to Coffee or Die Magazine, Scheller agreed to waive the right to appeal any adverse discharge decision to an independent review board. The secretary of the Navy will determine whether he receives a coveted honorable discharge or, more likely, a general discharge under honorable conditions.

The maximum penalty Scheller faced was the loss of two-thirds of his pay over the span of a year.

Scheller verdict brass conduct
Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller arrives to hear the judge’s verdict in his special court-martial trial Oct. 15, 2021, at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina. Photo by Noelle Wiehe/Coffee or Die Magazine.

Hines told Scheller during the Friday sentencing session that he viewed every video the lieutenant colonel posted and read all 612 pages of an internal investigation. He dubbed Scheller an officer with “a career on the upward slope until last month.”

“The court has weighed that heavily,” Hines said.

Hines called the leak of Scheller’s medical records, including mental health documents, by the brass to a media outlet unfair and potentially illegal, but he recommended other remedies for the officer outside of his court-martial sentence.

Prosecutors declined comment on Friday.

Scheller verdict brass conduct
Criminal defense attorneys Timothy Parlatore, left, and Jeremiah “Jay” Sullivan enter the Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, courthouse on Friday, Oct. 15, 2021. It was the second day of the special court-martial trial of Marine Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller. Photo by Noelle Wiehe/Coffee or Die Magazine.

The judge also eyed the conduct of the Marine Corps in the case and noted potential grounds for unlawful command influence, criminal defense attorney Timothy Parlatore said.

Called the “mortal enemy of military justice” by higher courts, unlawful command influence happens when leaders utter words or take actions that illegally guide the outcome of court-martial trials or undermine the public’s confidence in the armed forces by appearing to tip the scales of justice.

“That’s also a key reason why the judge kept asking Scheller questions about coercion,” said Parlatore. “Was his time in the brig used to coerce an outcome? It’s why he asked if the confinement was ‘severe’ and ‘unnecessary.’”

Scheller spent nine days in the brig, partly on the notion that he was a “flight risk,” a charge Scheller and his legal team strongly denied.

Hines mused that 99% of court-martial trials never move beyond a senior commander’s purview on a military base, but Scheller’s proceedings “appeared to have played out in a public forum,” thanks to the lieutenant colonel’s viral social media posts.

“It was a fair judgment,” said attorney Parlatore. “He put a lot of thought into it.”

Parlatore said the “most important thing” to emerge from the trial was the stark chasm between a Marine lieutenant colonel who pleaded guilty to all charges and asked to be held accountable for violating military law, and politicos and the Pentagon brass who haven’t suffered publicly for their stewardship of two decades of war overseas.

“If Stu Scheller is the only person held accountable here, and there’s never any institutional change that comes from this, then it’s a shame and a waste,” the attorney said.

Read Next: Scheller Speaks: Marine Uses Court-Martial To Blast ‘Unaccountable’ Brass

Carl Prine
Carl Prine

Carl Prine is a former senior editor at Coffee or Die Magazine. He has worked at Navy Times, The San Diego Union-Tribune, and Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. He served in the Marine Corps and the Pennsylvania Army National Guard. His awards include the Joseph Galloway Award for Distinguished Reporting on the military, a first prize from Investigative Reporters & Editors, and the Combat Infantryman Badge.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
dear jack mandaville
Dear Jack: Which Historic Battle Would You Want To Witness?

Ever wonder how much Jack Mandaville would f*ck sh*t up if he went back in time? The American Revolution didn't even see him coming.

west point time capsule
West Point Time Capsule Yields Centuries-Old Coins

A nearly 200-year-old West Point time capsule that at first appeared to yield little more than dust contains hidden treasure, the US Military Academy said.

Ouija Board aircraft carrier
Low-Tech ‘Ouija Boards’ Have Helped Aircraft Carriers Operate for Decades

Since the 1920s, a low-tech tabletop replica of an aircraft carrier’s flight deck has been an essential tool in coordinating air operations.

Army vs. Navy mascot
The Navy Goat vs. the Army Mule: Mascot Origin Stories

For nearly as long as the Army-Navy football rivalry, the academies’ hoofed mascots have stared each other down from the sidelines. Here are their stories.

ukraine long-range weapon
Zelenskyy Says Ukraine Has Developed a Long-Range Weapon, a Day After Strike Deep Inside Russia

Zelenskyy said on his Telegram channel the weapon was produced by Ukraine’s Ministry of Strategic Industries but gave no other details.

7 of the Best Movie Ambush Scenes of All Time

Ambushes make for great action scenes. Here are seven of the best to ever grace the big screen.

North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, center, with his daughter, center right, reportedly named Ju Ae, review the honor guard during their visit to the navy headquarter in North Korea
North Korea Launches Missile Toward Sea After US Flies Bomber During Drills

South Korea’s Joint Chiefs of Staff said in a statement that the launch occurred Wednesday but gave no further details, such as how far the missile flew.

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
Contact Us
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved