Marine Maverick Scheller Rebuts Reprimand From Corps

November 6, 2021Carl Prine
Scheller court-martial

US Marine Corps Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller pleaded guilty to all counts against him during an Oct. 14-15, 2021, special court-martial trial at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina. Composite by Coffee or Die Magazine.

A dozen days after outspoken Marine Lt. Col. Stuart P. Scheller pleaded guilty at court-martial for wielding social media to portray the military brass as unaccountable martinets unmoved by two decades of failures in Iraq and Afghanistan, the Corps hit back.

A bracing Oct. 26 letter of reprimand penned by Marine Training Command’s Maj. Gen. Julian D. Alford paints Scheller as a “narcissistic” officer who eroded the rule of law in the military through a series of social media posts and videos that called into question his leaders’ competence.

“You have violated your solemn oath to support and defend the Constitution of the United States,” Alford wrote. “Your actions have harmed good order and discipline within the service as well as publicly discredited the U.S. Marine Corps. Your narcissistic acts can serve only to erode the rule of law. You have failed in your duties to your command, fellow Marines, the U.S. Marine Corps, and the laws and traditions governing military service.”

court-martial Lejeune
Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller arrives for his special court-martial trial Oct. 15, 2021, at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina. Photo by Noelle Wiehe/Coffee or Die Magazine.

In his letter, Alford reminded Scheller that he was found guilty under military law for contempt; disrespect toward a superior commissioned officer; willfully disobeying a superior commissioned officer; dereliction of duty; failure to obey a lawful order; and conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman.

Scheller pleaded guilty to all charges at a Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, special court-martial and will leave the military three years shy of his 20-year pension. He drew a $5,000 fine and a letter of reprimand from a general officer.

But if Alford designed his stinging words to shut Scheller up, he failed.

Marine Scheller Reprimand
Marine Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller pleaded guilty Oct. 14, 2021, at a special court-martial after being charged with multiple violations of military law. Photo courtesy of The Pipe Hitter Foundation.

Two days after Alford signed the reprimand, the decorated combat infantry officer returned fire with a written response that called into question “the legality, content, and double standard” of the two-star general’s reprimand.

Instead of using any personal vitriol as ammo against Alford, however, Scheller largely borrowed from the public findings of his Marine special court-martial judge, Marine Reserve Judge Col. Glen R. Hines.

Scheller began his two-page rebuttal with a poke at Alford, who appears in the charge sheet as a victim of the lieutenant colonel’s broadsides and who was also the commander who convened Scheller’s court-martial. By writing the reprimand, the two-star general continued to create “a strong appearance of a conflict of interest,” Scheller said.

Although Scheller’s plea deal waived his right to invoke unlawful command influence as a defense, he urged the brass to name a “neutral and impartial” flag officer to write the reprimand, not Alford.

Termed the “mortal enemy of military justice” by higher courts, unlawful command influence happens when leaders utter words or take actions that illegally guide the outcome of court-martial trials or undermine the public’s confidence in the armed forces by appearing to tip the scales of justice.

scheller video
Marine Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller pleaded guilty at a special court-martial after being charged with multiple violations of military law for a series of videos and social media posts belittling his chain of command. Screenshot via a Scheller video.

Scheller also disputed Alford’s characterization of his actions as “narcissistic,” which the lieutenant colonel believes suggests a psychological personality disorder.

“I am not narcissistic,” Scheller wrote. “I was not diagnosed with this condition after the mental health screening your command ordered me to undertake.”

With a bitter sense of irony, Scheller pointed to the leak of his medical records, including mental health notes, to the media on the eve of the court-martial trial, an act that wasn’t lost on his court-martial judge.

Hines voiced concerns about how Scheller’s official files ended up in the hands of a reporter, calling the scandal “very disturbing,” “unfair,” “illegal,” and worthy of investigation since it also “creates the specter of unlawful command influence.”

Although Alford claimed Scheller had violated his oath to defend the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic, the lieutenant colonel wrote that Hines disagreed. He pointed to the judge’s findings that the Marine officer seemed rather to be a man “in pain,” “confused,” and “someone who was significantly frustrated,” not an oath breaker.

court-martial Lejeune
Criminal defense attorneys Timothy Parlatore, left foreground, and Jeremiah “Jay” Sullivan, right foreground, enter the Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, courthouse Oct. 15, 2021. It was the second day of the special court-martial trial of Marine Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller. Photo by Noelle Wiehe/Coffee or Die Magazine.

As for failing the Marine Corps, Scheller’s letter urges Alford to read the judge’s thoughts on the fitness reports the infantry officer’s 17-year career generated.

“I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone consistently marked in the top three marks of the Christmas Tree in the Reviewing Officer Evaluations,” Hines said. “Glowing comments from Reporting Seniors and Review Officers consistently. A career that appeared to be on the upward slope until last month.”

In his conclusion, Scheller noted the nine days he spent in solitary confinement inside the Camp Lejeune brig as a pretrial “flight risk.” His confinement occurred under Alford’s command. Scheller always insisted he wasn’t going to flee accountability for his words and deeds, and Hines noted how “very rare” it was to incarcerate a Marine before trial for the type of light charges the lieutenant colonel faced.

Scheller ended his rebuttal by mentioning the 13 US service members killed by an Aug. 26 suicide bomb attack at Hamid Karzai International Airport’s Abbey Gate. That tragedy during the withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan triggered Scheller’s crusade demanding brass accountability for bungled operations that got brave men and women killed there and in Iraq.

“I have accepted responsibility and accountability for my actions,” Scheller wrote. “I hope you ensure the same degree and accountability is exacted from those who unlawfully leaked my private records to the media, improperly ordered me confined to the brig, improperly denied me my basic needs in the brig, and, of course, failed in their duties to ensure that 13 service members did not have to die needlessly.”

Marine spokespeople did not reply to messages from Coffee or Die Magazine seeking comment.

Read Next: Who Stuffed These Cute Reindeer-Kitten Sculptures With Meth?

Carl Prine
Carl Prine

Carl Prine is a former senior editor at Coffee or Die Magazine. He has worked at Navy Times, The San Diego Union-Tribune, and Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. He served in the Marine Corps and the Pennsylvania Army National Guard. His awards include the Joseph Galloway Award for Distinguished Reporting on the military, a first prize from Investigative Reporters & Editors, and the Combat Infantryman Badge.

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
Curtis LeMay
Curtis LeMay: The World War II General Who Firebombed Japan

Who exactly was Gen. Curtis LeMay? And how did he become the commander who razed more than 60 Japanese cities during World War II?

eric smith marine corps commandant nominee
Highly Decorated Marine Officer Nominated To Be Next Commandant

President Joe Biden has nominated a highly decorated Marine officer who has been involved in the transformation of the force to be the next Marine Corps commandant.

USS Arizona
Profile of a Ship: USS Arizona

When the USS Arizona sank, it took 1,177 crew members with it. Today it remains beneath the water as a memorial to all those who lost their lives at Pearl Harbor.

b1 bombers bosnia
US Bombers Fly Over Bosnia in Sign of Support Amid Continued Secessionist Threats

A pair of U.S. Air Force B-1B Lancer bombers flew low over Sarajevo and several other Bosnian cities...

SR-71 Blackbird
SR-71 Blackbird: The Spy Plane That Could Outrun Missiles

Lockheed Martin’s SR-71 Blackbird was a government secret for years. Now retired, a newer version plans to take its place.

medal of honor recipient remains returned
Missing 73 Years, Medal of Honor Recipient's Remains Return To Georgia

Soldiers of the 9th Infantry Regiment made a desperate retreat as North Korean troops closed in arou...

dear jack
Dear Jack: My Battalion Is Out of Control

In this installment of “Dear Jack,” Marine veteran and amateur life coach Jack Mandaville advises a lieutenant colonel on how to restore order in the lower ranks.

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved