Supreme Court Denies Request of Air Force Officer Who Told His Commander ‘Nuts’

April 19, 2022Maggie BenZvi
supreme court

Brig. Gen. Anthony McAuliffe famously responded “NUTS” to the German request for surrender at the Battle of the Bulge. Lt. Col. Jonathan Dunn claims that his use of the same phrase in response to the order to get the COVID-19 vaccine was a sign of “resolve” and not meant as disrespect. Composite by Coffee or Die Magazine.

The Supreme Court handed a second straight defeat to a military member seeking relief from the Pentagon’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate, turning away an appeal by an Air Force Reserve lieutenant colonel who, when ordered to get vaccinated, sent a memo to his commander that said: “NUTS!”

Lt. Col. Jonathan Dunn’s one-word memo got him fired from his command, but his argument to the high court attempted to turn the tables on the idea of a religious exemption, arguing that the vaccine mandate itself had grown into “a religious ritual required as a condition of participating fully in civil society.” 

A string of lower court rulings have given some hope to many service members who have filed lawsuits after seeking exemptions from the military’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate, but Monday’s 6-3 ruling by the Supreme Court will likely dampen hopes that most of those cases will prevail at the highest court in the land.

The April 18 ruling followed Dunn’s lawsuit in the District Court for the Eastern District of California, asking for relief from punitive action due to his refusal to get the vaccine on religious grounds. When his request for a temporary injunction was denied, he appealed to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which also denied his request.

The Supreme Court denied his final request Monday. Justices Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch wrote that they would have granted the injunction.

The current justices of the Supreme Court. Justices Alito, Gorsuch, and Thomas indicated that they would have granted Lt. Col. Jonathan Dunn’s request for an injunction. Photograph by Fred Schilling, Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States.

Last month, the Supreme Court refused an appeal from a group of Navy SEALs who objected to the vaccine on religious grounds, with the same justices dissenting. In that appeal, Austin v. US Navy SEALS 1-26, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote, “The District Court, while no doubt well-intentioned, in effect inserted itself into the Navy’s chain of command, overriding military commanders’ professional military judgments. […] The president of the United States, not any federal judge, is the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces.”

Dunn, who until being relieved from command led the 452nd Contingency Response Squadron of the Air Force Reserve, has served in the Air Force for 18 years. Similarly to other cases protesting the COVID-19 vaccine mandate, Dunn maintained that the denial of accommodation based on his “sincerely held religious belief” was a violation of his rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. 

In addition, Dunn attested that he had already contracted the COVID-19 virus, most likely the Delta variant, and testing has shown that he retained antibodies against the vaccine. Therefore, Dunn argued, allowing him to serve would not put his squadron at risk or undermine the unit’s readiness.

“Because government leaders have described the vaccine as a moral obligation and have relegated the unvaccinated to lower social status with reduced civil rights, he believes this particular vaccine has taken on a ‘symbolic’ and ‘sacramental quality,’” his attorneys said in the application. “That makes COVID-19 vaccination a religious ritual required as a condition of participating fully in civil society—like ancient Roman laws requiring sacrifices to Caesar or Nebuchadnezzar’s ‘edict requiring worship of the golden statue.’”

supreme court vaccine
Brig. Gen. Anthony McAuliffe famously responded “NUTS” to the German request for surrender at the Battle of the Bulge. Lt. Col. Jonathan Dunn claims that his use of the same phrase in response to the order to get the COVID-19 vaccine was a sign of “resolve” and not meant as disrespect. US Army photo.

Upon being told by his commanding officer, Col. Gregory Haynes, that his request for religious accommodation had been denied, and he had five days to decide between receiving the vaccine, submitting a retirement request that would be denied due to his ineligibility, or officially refusing the vaccine in writing, Dunn sent the major general higher up his chain of command a one-word memorandum: “NUTS!”

While the “NUTS!” response was a reference to Brig. Gen. Anthony McAuliffe’s response to a demand that the 101st Airborne surrender at the Battle of the Bulge, Haynes took it as a sign of disrespect and removed Dunn from command, due to Dunn’s “conduct and lack of judgment following the denial of his religious accommodation request appeal.” 

Other Cases

At least three other military vaccination cases may soon be at the Supreme Court, including Doe v. Austin, Lembo v. Del Toro, and Navy SEAL 1 v. Biden, all of which allege that the government is illegitimately restricting the religious freedom rights of service members by not fairly adjudicating religious accommodation requests. 

In the case of Navy SEAL 1 v. Biden, the lower court has been supportive of the service members’ case, with Judge Steven Merryday of the District Court for the Middle District of Florida saying that the plaintiffs are “very likely” to prevail in their claim. 

“The military is well aware of the frailty of their arguments in defense of their practices,” wrote Merryday in his order approving a temporary injunction against punitive actions for two of the plaintiffs in the case.

supreme court vaccine
Hundreds of service members have now been administratively separated from the military for refusing the COVID-19 vaccination. Photo by Master Sgt. Matt Hecht.

Vaccine Exemptions, Separations

The Army has approved two religious exemptions out of 4,238 requests. The service has separated 255 soldiers from the branch so far.

The Navy received 3,352 active duty and 852 Individual Ready Reserve (IRR) requests for religious accommodation. It has granted 10 conditional approvals to IRR sailors, but they must be vaccinated prior to returning to active duty. It has also given 27 approvals to sailors who will be transitioning out of the Navy prior to June 1. There have been 804 separations for refusing the vaccine.

The Air Force has granted 37 approvals out of 7,784 requests for religious accommodation and has separated 261 active-duty airmen.

The Marine Corps, which shares its numbers to the press via email, has approved seven exemptions out of 3,697 requests. And 1,787 Marines have been separated due to vaccine refusal, according to Media Operations Officer Capt. Ryan Bruce.

Read Next: TRICARE Autism Post Raises Ire of Military Parents

Maggie BenZvi
Maggie BenZvi

Maggie BenZvi is a contributing editor for Coffee or Die. She holds a bachelor’s degree in political science from the University of Chicago and a master’s degree in human rights from Columbia University, and has worked for the ACLU as well as the International Rescue Committee. She has also completed a summer journalism program at Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism. In addition to her work at Coffee or Die, she’s a stay-at-home mom and, notably, does not drink coffee. Got a tip? Get in touch!

More from Coffee or Die Magazine
Curtis LeMay
Curtis LeMay: The World War II General Who Firebombed Japan

Who exactly was Gen. Curtis LeMay? And how did he become the commander who razed more than 60 Japanese cities during World War II?

eric smith marine corps commandant nominee
Highly Decorated Marine Officer Nominated To Be Next Commandant

President Joe Biden has nominated a highly decorated Marine officer who has been involved in the transformation of the force to be the next Marine Corps commandant.

USS Arizona
Profile of a Ship: USS Arizona

When the USS Arizona sank, it took 1,177 crew members with it. Today it remains beneath the water as a memorial to all those who lost their lives at Pearl Harbor.

b1 bombers bosnia
US Bombers Fly Over Bosnia in Sign of Support Amid Continued Secessionist Threats

A pair of U.S. Air Force B-1B Lancer bombers flew low over Sarajevo and several other Bosnian cities...

SR-71 Blackbird
SR-71 Blackbird: The Spy Plane That Could Outrun Missiles

Lockheed Martin’s SR-71 Blackbird was a government secret for years. Now retired, a newer version plans to take its place.

medal of honor recipient remains returned
Missing 73 Years, Medal of Honor Recipient's Remains Return To Georgia

Soldiers of the 9th Infantry Regiment made a desperate retreat as North Korean troops closed in arou...

dear jack
Dear Jack: My Battalion Is Out of Control

In this installment of “Dear Jack,” Marine veteran and amateur life coach Jack Mandaville advises a lieutenant colonel on how to restore order in the lower ranks.

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Careers
Contact Us
  • Request a Correction
  • Write for Us
  • General Inquiries
© 2023 Coffee or Die Magazine. All Rights Reserved